Showing posts with label All Business Analysis Articles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label All Business Analysis Articles. Show all posts

Sunday, 13 March 2011

Airtel Stock Analysis: Airtel Ranks No. 1 in Customer Complains: Time to rethink

Few days back, when the new emerging ET Now channel had a prime time news - Bharti Airtel gets maximum customer complaints: TRAI - I was not surprised. Being an Airtel customer for past many years and having faced the routine troubles, in a way I was satisfied to see that I am not the only one to face problems with Airtel - the majority is with me :) Airtel
Anyways, in this article We discuss the Airtel Business model, its advantages, disadvantages, its areas of improvements, what is going wrong with Airtel to do a stock Analysis of Airtel. A look at the nos reveal that Airtel complains were way above the rest - 3570 for Airtel compared to 2100 of the next highest Reliance Communications. That's a big difference of more than 75% higher complains.
Airtel is known to be one among the market leaders in the telecom space in India. With the acquisition in the African continent, it is the world's fifth largest telecom operation and telecom services provider.
What is the major area for customer complains?
The major area of customer complains is the same usual stuff - change to higher billing without notice, unsolicited activiation of chargeable services, no satisfactory resolution of complains.
Now, the biggest problem with Airtel is that it has started to charge its customers if they call up on their customer services no. 121. Ideally, this call should be free. But no, airtel is planning to save some money by reducing the no. of customer service representatives (and hence their salaries) and hence they are discouraging the customers to call on customer care nos. They expect customers to get that info by SMS or by logging onto airtel site on internet.
That, in my frank opinion, is really weird. India is not a country where you will find majority of the people feeling happy about getting info and updates through SMS - they are still not that tech savvy. People prefer to speak and listen - and that is the most effective way to win satisfying customers. Airtel seems to have got it wrong. The fact is that info is not available properly through SMS or Voice based services, and people are then forced to call. And when they are charged for it, they feel cheated.
With no. portability coming in, many individuals have switched. In fact another competitor, DOCOMO, had even advertised attacking this method of charging customer care calls - they advertised by explicitly mentioning "No charge for customer care calls".
Club these 2 things together - high no. of customer complains, and if you want a resolution for that you are charged for such calls. Won't the customers run away to other operators?

Advertising of Airtel?
It's a big question mark to me.
First, lets see what the competitors are doing in advertising space.
Idea has signed up with Abhishek Bacchan - they must be paying a big amount to him. They have also joined hands with six world cup captain from different countries with the concept of "Keep Cricket Clean". Still, that amount will not be that high. So bascially, Idea has one single brand ambassador.

Vodafone - we love the ZooZoo and the cute dogie. No brand ambassadors to pay. It's a great advertising concept and works far better than anyone else. The only people you need to pay is the ad agency. Highly effective and cost saving.

Docomo - Simple and effective. No high cost.

Now come to Airtel Advertising. Have a look at the list of "Brand Ambassadors" - Shahrukh Khan, Saif Ali Khan, Kareena Kapoor, even Saina Nehwal (for international roaming). Interestingly, they are all big superstars and must be costing a big amount to Airtel for being its brand ambassadors. Imagine, if the same amount of money being paid to 4 brand ambassadors had been reduced to a single one, and the saved money had been spent in keeping customers happy with no charges to call customer care, or paid back to the Airtel stock holders as dividends, it would have been much more beneficial to win loyal customers and satisfying stock holders.
It surprises to think that they are ready to pay multi million dollars to so called superstars, but not willing to offer satisfactory customer support.
The philosphy of hiring more and more "superstars" for brand advertisements needs a rethink. If a line of superstars was the only way to getting you more business, then Vodafone, Docomo, Idea would have collapsed by now. Rather, they are doing fairly well.

Rebranding exercise of Airtel - who bears the heavy cost?
So we all were happy to see the new logo of Airtel? Were we? Ask the shareholders.
The company management went for a new logo - justified it in several ways - red color for youth and energy, logo in small letter for showing humility, blah, blah, blah, etc., etc.
Every single poster on even a paan-shop, every single ad board on the street, everything was replaced with the new logo. Crores of Rs. were spent in this new rebranding exercise.
As per the news for last quarter results, the net income declined by a hooping 41%, and the company happily attributed it to the cost associated with rebranding exercise.
The big question is - who bears the heavy cost of this rebranding? It's you, the shareholders.
Another question - whether this was necesary? ANy analyst would say it was not. Are the customers deciding their telecom operator based upon their logo? Or based upon what color it is? Or based upon whether it is in small letters or capital letters?
The fact is that this was an unnecesary cost. It could have been paid back to the shareholders in the form of dividend or invested in improving business operations or providing better satisfying support to the customer. At the end, it came out as a loss. It's the shareholders who lost.

Other problems with Airtel:
There have been several other instances which force a customer to run away or switch to other operator.
Unwanted charges for services not requested is one common complain.
Then, all of a sudden, one fine day majority of the prepaid customers find that their connection is blocked. All they receive is an SMS saying that CUSTOMERS have not provided their full KYC details (Know Your Customer) details and asked to come to the nearest Airtel Relationship center.
Upon reaching the ARC, they find a big queue of people having the same problem. And this is not just with new customers, even old customers who are more than 5 years with Airtel were hit. Whose responsibility is it to follow KYC upfront?
Few years back in Maharashtra, one fine day all Airtel prepaid mobiles go off and the situation remains as it is for 3 days. Why? Because Airtel has a power problem at one of their towers. Later, an apology is published in national newspapers. What about the problems people faced for those 3 days?
All of a sudden, one fine day the internet tarrif is suddenly increased from 10 ps rate to 30 paise rate - Tripled. And then the customers are expected to remain loyal with more business.

Overall Airtel Stock Analysis?
Given the fierce competition going on in the Indian Telecom market, that too with MNP being available, it seems that with its current pricing and charges model, Airtel is bound to loose out on it market share. It will be the Docomos and Virgin mobiles who might hit it hard.
All the high costs involved in rebranding has already taken a hit on income. Its true that this does not happen very often, but Shareholders need to be aware about these management decisions, because its the shareholders who own the company and they get hit.
Then comes to African business they recently got into. Last Quarter results also mentioned that they had big forex losses because of forex currency price fluctuation. It is again going to take a toll on shareholder's investments.
3G plans have been lauched in Bangalore & Mumbai, but the cost is high.
Not sure whether they will benefit or loose out from MNP, but looking at the high no. of customer complains does not pose a rosy picture for Airtel stock.

Wednesday, 16 February 2011

Better Options for IT Engineers in India: Consider these careers

Being someone from the IT industry of India, I am sometimes seriously puzzled to know what to do and what is going on. Here I try to look for some options which can make an alternate choice for IT engineers like us :)
The IT industry in India has really boomed. It has provided millions of jobs to Young Indians, giving them fat pay packages compared to other sectors. However, as nothing in this world comes for free, so have been the tensions that these high end high paying IT jobs for the young generation.
We had earlier captured the essence of Indian IT industry and their dilemma through a picture in this article: Truth of the Indian IT industry?
Most of the young IT engineers come from their native middle and small towns of India. However, the IT jobs are not available in the same middle and small towns. They are forced to move to bigger metro cities, where cost of living is high. Despite that high cost of living, the fat pay packages allow these engineers to meet up their needs. But when it comes to settling down, there is a big problem. High cost of real estate, high cost of recurring expenses even after buying a property.
Typically, let's take the case a fresher from a middle size town. He has worked hard to get admission into an engineering college. Majority of these colleges are private, which take "high payments" and offer "Payment seats". Elderly parents dont understand the whole scenario - all they know is that an engineering degree of their son will open the gates of properity for them. So they make big payments (by self accumulated funds or taking loans) and get their kid admitted to an engineering college/MAC college. The kid is responsible, knows the hard earned money spent by his parents, works hard during his course to get good results and then finds a job for himself as a fresher.
Typically, the fresher salary starts in the range 10K per month to 25K per month (leave aside the real outliers).
For this salary, he works all day and night for the whole year, then comes the so called appraisal process.

How do I define the appraisal process?
It's basically multi-staged "fooling process" where the following stages go on:
Stage 1: Victim is forced to work all round the year
Stage 2: Then he is asked to "prove that he has actually worked" by filling in the self appraisal sheet
Stage 3: The appraisal discussion, where he has to display his fighting and convincing skills to prove that he really should get "5 on 5" for point appraisal points 1 and 3 and he can settle for "4 on 5" for point 2 and 5, while point no. 3 is forced onto him as "2 out of 5". This is the most lively stage.
Stage 4: The Decision Stage - where the new increments and bonuses are distributed. Irrespective of what you worked for, what you fought for, what you justified, you always get something around an "average"

End Result - More and more dissatifaction comes in.
So what to do? Haven't you ever heard some of the IT engineers saying that they want to leave this stream? At some point in time, everyone vents that anger.

More problem comes when these IT engineers have to face the public and the markets.
If you are an IT engineer, the auto-wallahs will charge you a premium.
If you are an IT engineer, be prepared to shell out more money for simple tasks like getting an affidavit, stamp paper, rent agreement, etc.
If you are an IT engineer, you will be expected to pay more to your maids, to the gas delivery boys, at the vehicle service stations, etc.
If you are an IT engineer, you cannot travel anything less than AC class in the train.
And if you happen to buy a property or apartment, then the builder will quote a "wallah".... IT guys have the money, let's take it.

So whatever one earns, goes off.
But what are the other options which are better paid then the high paid IT jobs? Consider these:
Being an IT engineer myself, I really envy these professios:)

1) Become a porter at a metro city railway station (Bangalore/Pune/Hyderabad/Delhi) :
Irrespective of the government fixed rates, a porter (and his union members) can demand whatever they wish. 2 suitcases carrying will cost as follows:
2nd AC: 250 Rs
3rd AC: 150 Rs.
Sleeper: 100 Rs.

Even at minimum 100 Rs. per ferry, just ferry 5 rounds per day, and hey you make a cool 500 Rs. per day or 15,000 Rs. per month (same as an average freshers salary)

2) Puncture Repairer in any metro city:
Some bikes/cars will come to you naturally. For increasing profits, you can throw 2-3 nails everyday on the streets and force increase your customers.
Develop "puncture increasing skills" - pull out the tube from the tyre so that it gets torn, or use hidden wires and nails to create more holes in the tube while checking for puncture.
Keep an assitant. When the vehicle owner is looking at the tube, the assitant can rupture the tyre.
Now, you replace the tube, stick some "high end rubber patches" to fix the tyres and charge heavily. Tube cost will be 200-250 Rs., the patch however small and cheap can be charged 100-300 Rs. per patch.
Daily turnover - atleast 2000 Rs. (Can IT engineers match this?)

3) Vehicle Service Station Mechanics/Supervisors:
Whether its an authorized service center of an automobile brand, or a local garage, these guys really know how to make money.
All you need to do is find faults and problems by talking highly automobile-intensive technical terminology and prove to the customer his vehicle really has many problems. Even if the problem can be fixed by tightening a screw instantly, never do that. Always say that "You will have to leave the vehicle for a day" - that increases the complexity and customers get the confidence that there is really something wrong.
Never go for repairing, always go for replacements. Repair cost is less. Replacement gives you the profit for selling new parts plus the labour charges.
You get a share of what you sell and repair. Another high paying job.

4) Plumber/ Electrician in metro city:
Another high paying job. WIth high end electric systems with conceled electric wiring/ conceled pipe systems in high end apartments, you are the king. Any fault that comes up, you have the command, both on repairs, replacements as well as the price.

5) Auto Rickshaw Driver:
How can this be left out? There are two options:
1) Charge as per government fixed rates - earnings will be low, and lot of hardwork
2) Charge as per your wish - work/ferry less, earn more

Pickup some unique spots in the city. Say from Railway Station to an IT park outside the city limits. Other rickshaw walas will not ferry there. You take the charge, ferry the needy passengers at your own rates. No options for the passengers forces them to pay you as you demand. Make 3-4 trips per day, and tease the educated IT guys

Monday, 7 February 2011

Inflation Problems? Majority of Indians should not worry

Usually the opposition targets Dr. Manmohan Singh - the PM of India, and his cabinate, for problems of inflation and economic issues going out of control. The justification that comes from the government is that things are driven by markets, things are driven by demand and supply, things are driven by international prices and hence there is not much the government can do about it.
There are a lot of examples that shows that government has been unable to tackle the increasing costs - be it sudden rise in the onion prices (as well as the prices rise of other vegetables), the cost of pulses, the hike in petrol rates, etc.

However, on the front of inflation, I am with the government and will completely take their side - especially for the justification that inflation has increased because people are earning more and more. Inflation
Unfortunately, we all see small clips of the statements made by government ministers on news channels. What is lost in these small clips is the context of the entire statement. We all know how well the Indian media behaves and what all is cooked up for breaking news (see example here - of "Responsible News" covered by Indian Media)
In this article, I attempt to highlight the cause of inflation in India and how it can be attributed to the increase in earnings of the individuals
First of all, we need to understand the various "financial stratas (layers)" that exist in the Indian society. Indian society is not a clear 3 layer society where you can clearly define people in 3 categories - poor, middle class and rich.
Indian society has many layers in financial terms - extra poor, very poor, poor, lower middle class, middle middle class, upper middle class, richer middle class, rich, richer, extra rich, super rich, really rich and so on.
Depending upon the (undefined) category you belong to, you have your spending power.

What the government ministers are trying to convey, and not being understood by the people, is that the earning power 9and hence the spending power) of countrymen has increased and hence the demand has increased and so the inflation is going up.

Let's understand this with a simply example.
A family of 4 lives in Mumbai in a 2 BHK rented flat. Father is around 45, works in a govt job and has a fixed salary. Mother is a housewife - no income for her. Son has just completed his engineering and has started earning - no plans to marry for atleast 4 years. Daughter is completing her 12th and looks forwards to getting into medical/engineering college. Typical Indian middle class family and here is how things progress.

Son has just started earning. Before that, the family was able to meet all the expenses from the father's fixed salary. So this salary income of son is "extra". What to do with this extra income now?
Spend or invest. The son has seen his parents toiling hard throughout their lives. He knows how they brought him up. So being a good son, he wants to keep his parents happy. Now with his salary income, he might start buying things for them. First it will be the necessities - clothes, mobiles, a new two wheeler - but this time a lot better. Why better? because he has extra surplus money. But better comes at a premium - at a bit higher cost. However, with the surplus income, he or the family doesnt mind paying extra.
The same family which used to buy clothes from local retail cloth shop, has now started visiting high end supermalls. The shirts for which cloth was purchased for 200 and stichting would cost another 200, making it a total of 400 Rs. for a shirt, are now being purchased from Shopper Stops, Lifestyles, Westsides or Pantaloons at a premium of 1200 to 2000 Rs. The grocery which used to be earlier purchased from local kirana shop with some bargaining, is now being purchased from Reliance Fresh and More, again at a premium. The vegeatbles which were purchased from the local subji mandi at lower prices with bargaining, are now being purchased from Fresh and More. So basically, the spending power has increased. With extra money, family is spending (and willing to spend) more, for the same commodities.

After these necessities (say after 2-3 months of salary), what to do now with the extra income?
Time for some big investments. How about buying a car? If few months salary is not sufficient, then there is car loan available.

Have been living in a rented apartment. The service of son has made him eligible for taking a big amount of home loan. Why not book a bigger flat on loan and move to a better high-end living?

The family which use to have problems with just 2 Rs petrol price hike, is not minding even if the prices are shooting up 5 times in a year.

This is what typically happens when earnings increase. The above example talks about only one family. We all know very well that today, every tom, dick and harry walking on the streets, is able to secure an engineering or mca degree and able to get a job in atleast a BPO. Am not implying anything in lack of skills or hardwork, but am mentioning the ease of getting educated (getting a degree), getting a job, and getting salary and hence extra pay leading to extra spending.

Why are the airconditioned supermalls running successfully? Because there are customers who are willing to pay extra for the same stuff which is available for cheap at a retail shop. Still, people want to buy from the supermalls at high price.
Why are the vegetables and grocery retail chains running fine? Again people are willing to pay more
Petrol and diesel prices are increased several times - do you see any fall in car sales or bike sales? No - infact, the sales have increased. Why? the people have more earnings, more money, and hence more purchasing power. Dont you know that many two wheelers and four wheelers have waiting periods for months? Because the demand is high.

Go to any Reliance Fresh or More store in a bit late evening. The IT and BPO workforce returning from the offices will be there. Even if the gates are going to be closed, they will beg for an entry at 9 or 9:30 PM at night. Even if the left over potatoes are not of good quality, they will pick up the best of the worst from the leftovers in these stores at the closing time. However, the same people will not buy good quality potatoes from a roadside vendor for the reason unknown to them - probably buying leftovers at high prices from a a/c superstore is a status symbol, but buying good quality stuff from roadside vendor at cheaper price is not.

Right from the small daily commodities like potatoes to high end luxuries like cars and houses, the demand is more and more.
This is what leads to high demand. And when the demand is high and supply is limited, the prices are bound to rise. And that leads to inflation.
Now think about it for a moment and ask yourself what can the government do for such price rise.
Honda Activa, the famous scooter has a waiting period of more than 6 months - Why? because people are willing to line up for that - high demand. Even after you buy it, to get it serviced in a metro city, you need to take an appointment 4 days in advance. Still people are willing to go for it. People will not be willing to purchase the readily available Scooty, Wego, Rodeo. Why blame the government for price rise?
The problem is with perception - we need high income, but we can't accept high cost. The same guy will not mind going to a movie in a multiplex for a ticket costing 300 per seat, snacks at Rs. 150, parking charges at Rs. 50. But if the housemaid working in his house at salary of Rs. 1000 asks for 100 Rs. raise, the same person will be upset.
It is for us to understand and accept that nothing in this world comes for free. The growth in income which we have seen, will lead to price rise. No point in complaining. Rather we should feel happy to be able to live such lavish lifestyles, despite high cost, just because of our high incomes

Friday, 28 January 2011

Google: What's Going Wrong with Google?

Today, we've been joined by a new member in the contributors group. He likes to called Monty and will be working on doing a "transperancy analysis" on companies, businesses, countries and more, in his own unique critical, hilarious style. Enjoy these articles from Monty
Hello Everyone. I thought of starting my venture on FT Times with something on the bigger businesses. The king of Internet - Google!
Why I selected Google? Well, I really like it's search engine. No, I'm not talking about quality, but about the way it initially designed itself in the beginning (and in turn forced other search engines to become algorithm based rather than directory based).
It was Google Search Engine which enabled each individual on this planet to find info on the internet, if not in the first few results, atleast some relevant info somewhere down the line. Quality I will discuss later. Google LogoGoogle Logo from Google.com
Another reason for taking on Google as a topic was the recent developments. The Google Chairman, Eric Schmidt, recently stepped down, declared to sell his Google Shares.

One thing I really like about the corporate world is any news - good or bad - is conveyed in such a good diplomatic way that it appears to be a really positive news. So there we had it - on the Official Google Blog - Eric posted his message about how positive development this is going to be (See Google Blog Post by Eric. It appears that Google does not need any "adult supervision" anymore.
However, the world around the corporates - the media, the analysts and all - have their own ways of interpreting the information. So The Guardian quoted the news as saying Eric is actually being replaced by Larry Page. Moreover, Eric is going to sell a good enough portion of Google shares.
Eric was instrumental in many things - he was there with Google for more than a decade, was instrumetal in making Google a public listed company, and all of a sudden, his "adult supervision" was no longer needed.
The market was shocked at such development.

Now let's see what led to this situation (offcourse in my style and from my perspective):
- In essence, Eric has made way for Larry, the founder of Google.
- "No Adult supervision needed" is something which might indicate the need for new innovation, new ideas and their successful implementations
- May be that is something Eric failed to drive, so the company goes back to the basic roots - innovation in areas where it failed
- Company did grow with Eric, but the growth appeared only in no. of employees but no new innovative and materialistic money generating products coming in
- More problems than businesses - Google locked horns with governments and other regulatory authorities - for eg. had to leave China

Where did it suffer setbacks?
Almost everywhere. Let's have a look it in a dialogues form (Again, my perspective, just in a good format :-)

Q: Hey Google, what happened to the venture into the mobile phone business? (We questioned it earlier also Google Nexus One Phone: Does Google really need it?)
Google: Yeah. We did that well (we suppose). So what if we fail to make a mark. So what if there were already cheap (and better) smartphones available from Chinese market at lower prices. We did try our innovations!
We kept our employees happy by distributing the nexus to them.

Q: How about the social media failures?
Google: Failures - what failures? Dont you know we created a lot of "Buzz", then we already had "Orkut" (heard that name before), then we surfed on the "Wave". We're still experimenting.

Q: OK, Gmail is still the best?
Google: We believe. The so called gmail killer by Facebook still does not exist. Gmail is loved by all

Q: How about the Apps market?
Google: Well, there are some news that Apps market is not picking up. But that's fine.

Q: Chrome did do really well - fast browser built up the market share in no time
Google: Yes, that's what we are banking upon. We even invited selected US based users to participate in the lucky draw and get a Chrome based netbook free for trial. Looking forward to it.

Q: Now to the core - what about your search stats and quality?
Google: Quality - who questions our quality, we decide the quality.
Remember the buzz - "Google takes more than 200 parameters into account for search engine rankings". What they are, nobody will ever know (probably even google doesn't)
We keep experimenting - it now appears that anything on any news websites will be given precedence. So whether you search for an "XYZ Review", all one will get to see is news websites which dont really contain a review, but generic news information about XYZ. So search for a "review" will lead you to "news".
Although there are some really good authentic sites included in "Google News", we also accomodate some copy-cats. (There should be room for all). After all, we take the call. No problems if users get unhappy with the results in a small no. of cases.

Q: What about Spam Handling?
Google: Spam is what we are fighting with at the moment. So what if we have to block lots of sites and blogs. It does not matter who published what at what point of time. If our algorithms believe that it is spam, so it is. We've pulled the plugs - let the "spammers" suffer.
A small guy publishes a good original content on his small blog. After sometimes, Big guys copy it on their Big site (including Google News verified sites).
In our ways, Big guy is big, so it must be the small guy who has copied from the big guy. So punish the small guy and call him a "spammer". We have fool-proof algorithms to do that. Unfortunately, despite our algorithms take 200+ parameters into consideration, our algorithms aren't smart enough to take publish time into consideration - whether the small guy published it first or the big guy copied it later.
Even though our increasing headcounts are being questioned by Wall street analysts, we still rely on our algorithms to decide what is spam. We dont have enough people to decide the spam - that task is outsourced to our algorithms - they take the call. Spammers are out!
The internet is our kingdom, we'll clean it up the way we want it. End of the Story!

Q: What are the future plans?
Google: Looking forward to some more innovations under the new leadership.
We're doing a lot of experiements - Solar Panels Energy: Angle of Solar Panel Tilt Correlation: Google Experiments
After all, there are more things to do than search.
End of Q&A.

Now, Google appears to be in a transition phase. From a company working from a garage, to the internet search engine king, to the public listed company, to the business expansion in non-core markets and now back with the founders in the driving seat.
The "Do No Evil" company needs more insights for capturing the market share. Already, lost grounds in China and similar other countries with huge population. Remember, Google clients are commmon people (apart from a handful of corporates).
The "Spam" elimination exercise has already made a lot of people furious. Publishers, Bloggers have turned their back to Google.
Search being its core, is taking a hit. Everything in top search results comes from NEWS websites. Seems like the algorithm needs a rethink.
Support - does it really provide any? Everything is left to volunteers who "try" to help on open forums. No questions can be asked, no answers can be demanded, no liability. This is where it needs to work on.
With other search engine giants like Bing and Yahoo coming out in a big way, dont be surprised if Google starts loosing its search market share also. It needs improvement, and quickly. Twitter and Facebook are way ahead - Technology runs at a rapid pace

Copyright Information:
© http://invest-n-trade.blogspot.com
Please see Our Copy Right Policy. All the articles, posts and other materials on this website/blog are copyrighted to the owners of this portal. The content should NOT to be reproduced on any other website or through other medium, without the author's AND owners' permission.

DISCLAIMER: Before using this site, you agree to the Disclaimer.

About UsAdvertise with UsCopyRight Policy & Fair Use GuidePrivacy PolicyDisclaimer