Showing posts with label fund managers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fund managers. Show all posts

Tuesday, 1 January 2008

Mutual Fund: invest with caution and through right channel

I do not usually like to repeat information and news, but this one is good enough for the investors who have deep trust and faith in the Mutual fund investments.

I have always been against the charges that are taken from the investors in the name of fund management, entry load, exit load, distribution costs, etc. and that is why I always say that better to go for ETF’s instead of Mutual Funds. However, some respite is being offered by SEBI to the mutual fund investors.

As a new year gift to the investors,The SEBI has finally approved of waiving off the mutual fund investment entry load charges. What this means is the entry load charges when you invest into by buying a mutual fund units will not be applicable. This will save you something like 2.5% of your money.

However, there is an important point to understand clearly about investments in Mutual funds and getting the entry load waiver. The condition is that you MUST directly apply to the Mutual Fund house, instead of routing your application through your broker or agent. This point is very important to understand because people are still under the impression that if they have an online trading account with a broker, they can simply apply online for any mutual fund and they will not be charged any entry load.

My understanding is that this is NOT the case. Please verify it by calling your broker.

The mutual fund entry load charges will be waived off IF AND ONLY IF, you apply directly to the Mutual Fund company, (Mutual Fund AMC or Asset Management Company), which is offering the mutual fund. Hence, if I am willing to invest in the HDFC mutual fund, then I MUST apply directly on the website of HDFC mutual fund, by using my debit card. OR, I should go to the office of HDFC Mutual Fund in my city and fill in a paper form and submit a check to apply.

As per my understanding, if my stock broker allows me to apply for mutual funds through online trading on his website (like icicidirect.com or sharekhan.com) and I apply through my online brokerage account, then I WILL be charged the entry load. The reason is that even if I am applying online, the online application is being routed through my broker (or his website), hence it is NOT a direct application, so I should not get any entry load waiver. Please verify it with your broker and confirm whether you will be charged entry load or not. (The above is as per my understanding of rules).

Who would be affected? It will be the agents and middlemen who have been making around 4% to 8% of money who will loose their business. Secondly, the small fund houses who do not have online application facility and do not have significant presence in different parts of the country will be affected, because they rely upon these agents to sell their mutual fund products. However, in the name of saving the entry load money, the investors will now apply directly to the fund houses or AMCs and so these small funds with limited presence and no online application facility will be hurt.

Still the problem may not be solved. They entry load has been vanished, but it is possible that the mutual fund industry, which is the bread and butter of stock brokers and agents, may come up with some other charges, or increase the exit load charges and so on to recover the cost. No guarantee how the market will work – its only in a name.

Invest wisely, first understand the rules and act accordingly! Wishing everyone a New Year with healthy and fruitful returns! Table of Contents

Thursday, 6 December 2007

Islamic Mutual Funds: Sharia Mutual Funds

Recently, there has been a big hike in Islamic banking and Islamic investment instruments and financial products.
Along with US, UK, Middle East and Europe, India too is expected to catch up soon with financial products that comply with Islamic principles of money management and investments.

In this article, I will try to cover the basic principles behind the Islamic financial instruments and their working. A good example of "How Islamic Mortgage Work?" is available here (Opens in a new window)

As per the Islamic laws, charging interest on any transaction is illegal This forms the basis of Islamic investments and mortgages. Hence, it becomes difficult for Muslims to take up loans like home loan, mortgage or any other financial transactions, if they have to strictly comply with their religious faith and Shariyat laws.

Sharia scholars on the council prohibit investments in businesses that charge interest or have a debt ratio greater than a third of their assets. Industrial companies that have financing units, such as Ford Motor Co. and General Electric Co., are among those failing the test. Hence, no investments can be made in these companies. Banking is not the sector for Islamic investments, unless it is an Islamic bank working on Islamic principles.

The Islamic mutual funds also can't invest in companies that generate operating income from un-Islamic activities, including pork processing, tobacco, liquor, pornography and gambling operations. That takes away big companies like Benson and Hedges, Liquor companies, lot of online website companies, etc.

Typically, they end up investing in Energy stocks, like Exxon Mobil and BP, Utilities companies such as FPL Group Inc., textile stocks, etc.

Luckily for moneyed Muslims, there are a number of Islamic Financial Institutions (IFFs) out there catering to the needs of the devout. Over 250 of them to be exact managing funds totalling more than $300 billion (as per data for 2006). And with more and more Muslims interested in pious repositories for their assets, even financial institutions in the West are getting into the act.

According to the Koran, trade is allowed but not interest. Thus Muslims are forbidden from paying or earning interest on their investments and Islamic banks cannot lend their money in the form of credit. Furthermore Muslims cannot invest in companies counter to their religious beliefs, such as those involved in alcohol or gambling, pork products, pornography, or armaments.

The world market is fast growing in for the Islamic Mutual funds and investments. Middle-east has been the front runner in the race to launch the Islamic investment products and funds, but US and Europe did not take much time to identify the opportunity and join the race. The world is already full of financial products and investment instruments that fulfill the Islamic laws of investment.

Not only across the globe, Indian markets are also fast developing such funds. Recent hype in Indian financial industry has led the mutual fund management companies to look into the money management industry complying with Islamic principles, because they know very well that India houses the second largest muslim population in the world (just after Indonesia). Millions of Muslims are still not betting their money in financial instruments just because their working does not comply with their religious faith.

Coming to the returns from such funds, the same concept applies here. Since these kind of funds are restricted to a set of industry sectors, their performance depends upon how the sectors and their stocks have performed. There is no guarantee of anything.
Be prepared to see loads of funds coming in the market very soon.

Thursday, 29 November 2007

Review of Lotus India Agile Fund (Quant Based Fund)

Lotus India Asset Management company has recently launched a so called quant based mutual fund that is aimed at investing in such a fashion that it will eliminate human errors and select the stocks based on a computer generated algorithm.

I liked the punch-line “Eliminate Human Error” and depend upon computer algorithms for stock selection and portfolio churnings.

At last, there is one such fund house that agrees that fund management can contain human errors. Should it mean that other previous funds from Lotus AMC (and other fund houses), are not worth the investor’s trust, as they may be full of human errors?

The fund has the standard rate as per other funds – 2.25% at entry load, 1%, 0.6% and Nil exit load based upon the time you exit after remaining invested in the fund.

As per the details:
Lotus India Asset Management Company Monday launched Quant based scheme, Lotus India AGILE Fund (Alpha Generated from Industry Leaders Fund).

Quant funds operate on the basis of computer generated mathematical models. The investment objective is to generate capital appreciation by investing in a passive portfolio of stocks selected from the industry leaders on the basis of a mathematical model.

The new fund offer priced at Rs 10 per unit.

The fund will invest 90-100 per cent in equity and equity related instruments and 0-10 per cent in debt and money market instruments.

The fund offers two options--Growth and Dividend. The Dividend option offers Dividend Payout and Dividend Re-investment facilities.

Lotus India Agile Fund is an open ended equity scheme that will invest in 11 stocks (9 per cent each) determined by a mathematical model. The portfolio will be reviewed and reset every month.

The fund wants to limit itself to only 11 stocks. Can the algorithm be efficient enough to select the best performing 11 stocks always?

If the fund is so good and (human) error free, then why are there entry and exit loads as any other standard fund? Can the AMC give any guarantee of even 1% returns?

Can a computer really work better in predicting stock prices for the future? Elderly people are now going to cyber-cafes to match the horoscopes of their child with those of their prospective life-partners. All that happens is that crap software like “Kundli” uses stored information and matches the horoscope. Hardly anyone will understand anything, yet the elderly, without having any basic knowledge about a computer, will be happy to use it to match horoscopes.

Even if someone designs an algorithm to predict future stock prices, it all has to be based upon historical data and publicly available market information. Nothing better than a computer matching horoscopes.

No quantitative model can work efficiently ever after to pick up the stock market winners month after month consistently.

This fund is nothing but “Old Wine in a New Bottle”. Same old fund management charges, same old stock selection tricks disguised in the name of quantitative models.

Investors may try their luck by betting!

Wednesday, 3 October 2007

Fund Management at B-Schools - I

Have a look at this article making waves across major newspapers and even on a few business channels: B-school students cut their teeth on stocks

This article talks about various students at top and middle rung business schools of India getting into the business of fund management by collecting money from their fellow students. Using this collected money, they do the stock picking and give fabulous returns to the “investor colleagues”.

Here is an expert from the article

1:
Be it the Investment Bank of Kozhikode at IIM-K or Arth (inspired by the Arthshastra) at the National Institute of Industrial Engineering or Unnati at Management Development Institute, Gurgaon or Credence Capital at IIM-Lucknow, students are assuming the responsibility of managing kitties amounting to a few lakhs amidst the volatility in the capital and money markets.

2:
“Returns too have been exceptional,” said Anupam Dubey, one of the fund managers at NITIE. While net asset value — loosely, the current market value of investment — of NITIE’s fund was 14 last year, it is up by four points now.

3:
"We sit up till about two in the morning tracking stock movement. Besides, we speak to our alumni and our faculty for guidance. But in the last year, our fund has had returns to the tune of 30%-35% on the sensex stocks and about 60% on the mid cap stocks," Balaji added.


Actually, lots of other sentences can be picked up from the article.

Being myself a student at an international business school, that too doing a specialization in finance, investment and trading, I salute the spirits of the student fund managers for taking the courage to collect the money and take the responsibility of investing it, and I also thank the fellow student investors who have shown confidence in their colleague student fund managers, allowing them to invest the money on their behalf.

It is definitely a very good learning experience as a student and if things go well, the achievements can be added as “flash cards” on to the resume, so as to get hunted by the potential recruiters to get a job of your dreams.

A team member of mine at my previous job is presently studying at NITIE. On his Gmail Profile, he has placed a link to this article and placed his status as “Arth - The Quasi Mutual Fund of NITIE" rocks,” followed by a link to the above article. Very recently, he joined the fund management team.

Though it will be easier for anyone to claim that quote no. 2 is not good, as the investment has grown only from 14 to 18, while Nifty based ETF has returned better than that
OR
from quote no. 3 that 30-35% on Sensex and 60% on mid cap stocks is not upto the mark compared to the overall market rise or the respective ETF returns

But I want to remain positive on this development :- )

One thing that I like about this style of learning is that the students are betting either their own money or they are taking money from the colleagues who trust them. It is the perfect way of learning practically – do your own experiments, setup your own apparatus and then enjoy the rewards or failures yourself. So kudos to the students of these funds.

Continue to Part II

Fund Management at B-Schools - II

This is part II of the article Fund Management at B-Schools – I. Please read the article from the first part before continuing with this one

But I cannot stop myself from adding a note of caution :- ) (As always)

When the entire market and country is going euphoric about the stock markets, Sensex and Nifty touching record highs each day consistently, then it is easy to garner positive returns.

There are few things that one should keep in mind:

• The article mentions that the funds are being mentored by seniors, alumni and professors of the institute. Are the student fund managers learning the facts about how to compare the returns against the market index and see how they have performed?
• Are the student managers able to understand the fundamentals of stock picking? (though, in my opinion, there are no such stock picking fundamentals :- )
• Can they see whether their fund returns are atleast comparable to the returns offered by respective ETFs?
• As of today, the funds are working as small entities with small amounts. Are the future fund managers learning that there will be a big amount of money if they have to manage a fund professionally (Like Reliance MF has assets worth 70,000 Crore Rs.)
• I believe (though I may be wrong) that legal aspects of MF investments may not be covered in these small college based unregistered funds. Though these will be covered once the student fund managers join the professional fund management organizations
• They are in the process of getting the funds registered. I believe that is a very good move – it will ensure that the legal requirements as well as practical problems in a registered regulated fund will then help the student fund managers to get a practical understanding of the money management
• Most Important of all – are the professors, along with other mentors, informing the students about the efficiency of the markets and other available financial instruments like ETFs and Index funds?

I hope to see these small funds growing big, registered and regulated. But I will not be happy if the registered student funds start collecting money from common man. It will then defeat the purpose of fund management learning.

To all student fund managers, kudos to you all and keep up the spirit – just make sure that you keep your learning practices to your own money (of yourself, your alumni and fellow students).

Have questions, please read the comments and post your views and queries in the comments section which helps in open discussion and avoids duplicity of questions.

You may be interested in reading my previous articles. Here is the link to Table of Contents in a chronological order.

Monday, 17 September 2007

Tracking Errors in Index Funds – I

There has been a long waiting request from some of the readers about Index Funds and exchange traded funds (ETF), on how to gauge their performance with respect to the Index they are tracking.

In this article, I’ll present the details on how one can check whether the Index Fund of ETF is exactly tracking the index, and most importantly, how tracking error works.

As I’ve explained in my previous articles Index Fund v/s ETF, Index fund and ETF differ in the way they are traded. ETF can be bought as a single stock, while IF can be bought only as Mutual fund units.

Both ETF and IF try to follow one of the available market indices – it can be DowJones, NASDAQ, NIFTY, Sensex, etc. Sector specific funds like UTI Infrastructure fund will be trying to follow the Infrastructure Index, while a Index fund based upon investments primarily in Banking sector may follow BSE Bankex Index. Ultimately, every single fund that exists in the market follows an index, and this index is known as its BENCHMARK index.

Why a fund needs a Benchmark index?

A fund needs to show how well it performing, to attract the investors. The simplest way for a fund to do so is by comparing itself against an already existing market index. Hence, let’s say there is an Index fund based on Sensex or Dowjones Index. If, at the end of a year, an investor wants to see how has the Index fund performed, he can simply compare the returns from the Sensex or Dowjones, to that generated by the Index fund. This gives them a benchmark to gauge the performance of the fund.

How to check for the Index Fund follow up with the benchmark Index

That’s where the “tracking error” concept comes into picture. The simplest and the most basic definition of tracking error is that it is defined as the difference in returns between fund (portfolio) and benchmark index.

Continue to Part II

Tracking Errors in Index Funds – II

This is part II of the article Tracking Errors in Index Funds –Part I. Please read the article from Part I, before continuing with this part.

An example, let’s say you invested in XYZ Index fund that is tracking Dowjones Index. Suppose your XYZ Index fund returns 12%, while Dowjones returns are 15%. Hence the tracking error for the XYZ fund becomes -3% with respect to its benchmark index.

In essence, the “tracking error” tries to track the performance of a Fund with respect to its benchmark index. It is not only an indication of the performance of the fund with respect to its benchmark index, but also a sign of how much risk is their in the fund. Continuing the example mentioned above, the fund is having a tracking error of -3%, which shows that it has performed worse that the benchmark. Also, the risk is high; 3% with respect to the index return of 15% is actually 20%. Hence, there is a 20% more risk involved in this index fund, with respect to the benchmark.

Now, why should we care about the tacking error?

It’s true that it is based upon historical data, which does not guarantee anything for the future. But actually, Tracking error can be quite useful to observe how your fund manager is playing around with your money, how is his investment pattern and what kind of risk taker he is.

Whenever there is a new fund introduced, it has to declare its investment pattern and style. Say the offer document of an index fund says that the fund will track Sensex, and its tracking error is showing consistent deviation from the Sensex, that means that fund manager is not actually able to keep up his promised investment style. He is either deviating from his investment pattern declared in the offer document, or is paying/taking extra commission or transaction charges which are hampering the performance of your invested money.


Why does this error come in?
The main reasons why tracking error values are high are as follows:

1. High Transaction costs and commissions: They eat up the return on your invested money

2. Time log of tracking the benchmark index: Benchmark Index changes its value every second. The fund manager should churn his portfolio so as to exactly replicate the benchmark index constituents, as explained in my previous article. However, the problem is that frequent change in portfolio incurs lots of transaction costs. Hence, portfolio changes can be done only once in a while. This is the major reason for tracking errors

3. Change in Benchmark constituents: Another reason for tracking error. Primarily, a new entrant into the Benchmark index becomes very costly by the time the fund manager buys it. While an outgoing stock becomes very cheap by the time he sells it. As a result, low returns, hence a big tracking error.

Ultimately, the fund manager cannot track any underlying index to the point. Though he tries to claim that he is tracking a particular index, he will never be able to meet its performance because of transaction costs. Hence, ultimately he starts to deviate from the benchmark index constituents. That is what leads to the tracking error.

So choice is yours! Realize the truth that fund managers cannot replicate the index exactly. They end up gambling with your money based upon the beliefs that they can outsmart the index. The result are as shown in the graph of the article Should you trust your fund manager?

Please read the comments and post your views and queries in the comments section which helps in open discussion and avoids duplicity of questions.

You may be interested in reading my previous articles. Here is the link to Table of Contents in a chronological order.

Wednesday, 5 September 2007

Fidelity Fund: Super Distributor Market

Fidelity is planning to enter the Indian market within the “Super Distributor” segment.

Fidelity, one of the very big financial products and asset management companies of the world already owns Fundsnetwork, which currently covers a 1,000 funds of 55 fund management companies. The total value of assets under management for Fidelity AMC is more than 1. trillion dollars.

Now it is trying to revamp the Indian financial products market, or the mutual fund market, with a platform, which may not strictly be a distribution platform, but entails more than just asset management and one that would possibly make Fidelity, a super distributor of financial products.

How does it work?
There are these general distributors – who get the fund units directly from the AMC or asset management company, and they sell it to the investors for a commission. Suppose, a New Fund Offer, NFO, is planned by a AMC. XYZ distributor takes 10% of the fund unit from the AMC and attempts to sell it to common public. The AMC pays the distributor a commission for the mutual fund units sold by the distributor. So, there can be many regular distributors and AMC deals directly with them.

In case of a Super distributor, a financial product providers like AMC or fund management company pays the entire commission to the super distributor - which in turn deducts costs and its own fee and then passes the remaining commission to the regular or retail distributors or agents.
Hence, the super distributor not only earns from the AMC or fund management company, but also benefit from charging its network distributors.

As of now, there is only Reliance Money which is acting as a Super Distributor, that too partially. Fidelity, if gets successful in its plans, will be the first financial products company to be a super distributor.

What does this mean for the common investors?
On one hand, individual investors can expect a one-stop-shop for all kinds of financial products under one roof – like a financial super market. For regular distributors, each one ties up with a specific no. of AMCs. So one distributor may offer products from Morgan Stanley. But if you want to buy products from Goldman Sachs, you may not get it from the same distributor. You will be required to approach another agent.

Problem is that nothing comes free in this world. So the investors may expect more charges to be levied from them for buying financial products like mutual fund units from such super distributor chains. Remember, the more no. of entities involved in the supply-chain, the more cost it incurs to the end user. In case of financial supply chain network, the end user is the investor, who bears the entire cost.

On one hand, SEBI is trying to get rid of the entry load commissions , while on the other hand, such developments by big financial giants are indicating more costs for investments.

The financial services companies argue that in the long run, it will be beneficial for the investors, because in the long run, the prices will come down as is happening with the case of retail supermarkets being opened. However, the retail supermarkets and financial markets work on different patterns. One is consumer driven, other is commission driven. Despite knowing that investors hate to pay hefty commissions, no fund management company has reduced the commissions or charges so far.

Ultimately, the choice is left to the investors. Understand the costs and charges involved and make a right and justified selection. Or just go and pay the charges.

Please read the comments and post your views and queries in the comments section which helps in open discussion and avoids duplicity of questions.

Most Read Articles

-Simplest Investment Strategy

-Insurance Investments v/s Tax savings

-Are you really making money from stocks

-Should you trust your Mutual Funds manager?

-Traders, Market Makers and Individuala

-Buying Insurance or Pension Plans

-Do stocks guarantee good return in the long run?

-ETF- Exchange traded fund -An example

-Investment Management Strategies


You may be interested in reading my previous articles. Here is the link to Table of Contents in a chronological order.

Sunday, 2 September 2007

Financial/Investment Projects failure - Part I

In this article, let’s discuss how and why a project that any company undertakes may fail. More importantly, how do the project managers decide about taking up a project and whether they keep on investing in a project that may be a very risky investment, highly prone to failure.

In a few of my previous articles, I’ve talked about the personal psychological biases that individuals have in their minds. These biases act when the individuals take financial decisions, shop around, behave in a social network and basically, in all situations. The same goes true for financial managers and investment experts.

Do a self assessment: Remember when you’ve bought a stock and it turned out to be a loss making investment for you. Did you sell it off immediately to cut your losses? Did you immediately changed your mind and convinced yourself that this is not a good stock so let’s get rid of it. Most of the times, the answer to the above questions will be NO. The reason is the human nature, whatever we do, whatever we believe, whatever we think, we get possessive about it. In the investments world, it is more common for people to hang on to their loss making stock purchases because they have all kinds of reasoning: “Let me average it out by buying more stocks”, OR “Stocks give better returns in the long run, let me hold onto it”.

The same is true for the investment and project managers also. They take up new projects. These projects are either allotted to them by the higher management or they do their own research and come up with ideas which the higher management approves. Hence, they get possessive about their ideas and the project that they are going to undertake and are willing to risk the money for investing in the project.

It is usually claimed that merely 4% to 5% of the research work actually goes into real production and implementation. The rest 95% of the research work is wasted. That sounds quiet affirmative, because if majority of the research work would have been a success, the world would have become perfect centuries ago.

Now given these kinds of success rates, the projects that managers take up in the company are also prone to high level of failures. Yet the managers risk the money on such projects and go along betting on the success of the project and the product.

Let me take a simple example here. I guess almost all of us should have seen the Cadbury’s Bournvita 5 star ad on the TV, which shows a few kids waking up at midnight, then jumping over the fence to a nearby cricket stadium, then breaking into the electricity control room, studying a complex circuit design and finally lighting up the flood-lights and turning the light panels so that it focuses on their houses or flats. Then, these intelligent smart kids go back to their respective houses and wake up their moms and demands Bournvita 5 star drink, because they have created an effect of daylight using the stadium floodlight. The moms wake up, prepare bournvita, give them to the kids and later discover that it is still midnight, while their kids have done a great job by using floodlights to fool them. They seem to be convinced that they kids are very smart and Bournvita have made them intelligent enough to get up at midnight, break into the nearby stadium, study a complex circuit diagram and fool their own moms for want of Bournvita. :- )

Now, if I look at the entire theme, I get the impression that these “Bournvita” kids are actually the biggest dumb creatures on the planet. They have the intelligence to get up at midnight, break into the nearby stadium, study a complex circuit diagram and fool their own moms, but they don’t have the basic knowledge about preparing a glass of bournvita on their own for themselves. Is that what Bournvita does to kids – making them hardworking fools instead of making them fundamentally intelligent. I’m sure Bournvita didn’t had the idea of creating this kind of impression through this ad. However, the ad is still on air and is telecasted everyday.

Remember, this ad is company from the most popular health drink of the country, and that too from a reputed company called Cadburys, which has presence in majority of the countries across the globe. Before coming up with an advertisement, the advertisement and marketing team does a lot of study and surveys to identify things that will affect customer’s buying decision, they spend millions on producing the ad, then they pay for every second the ad is displayed on various channels. Everything costs money – yet companies do such mistakes. The same goes for investments in risky projects. Whatever ideas managers come up with, they get possessive about it and are willing to take the risk. Though chances of success may be limited, still they bet the money (basically stock investors’ money) on it.

The worst part of the above situation is about identifying the lapses in a project, when it is already sanctioned. A project is sanctioned, budget is allotted to it, the work commences, and then it is discovered that there are some problems. Still the project is taken ahead. The managers try to find some patch-ups to make up for the mistakes and lapses and carry on with the project. The motive behind it is that if the project is successful even with a low success rate, there will be good incentive for the manager.

Continue to Part II of this article

-(2)-Financial/Investment Projects failure - Part II

This is part II of the article: Financial/Investment Projects failure - Part I, Please read the article from the beginning before continuing with this part.

Take the case of same bournvita ad. Even though the ad creates an impression that bournvita drink may create dumb kids, still it is continuously aired on TV channels, which is costing millions of Rs. The reason, after investing so much in the study/surveys and in production of ad film, the team still hopes to capitalize upon the effort and hence is still paying for every second the ad is aired.

Remember the following names: King 100, Safari, Nova, Kine, Zing, Stryker, Comet, Aquila. Chances are that you may have hardly heard these names. They are all two wheelers from Kinetic which were launched, but failed miserably. Occasionally, you may see one of them on the road, but you will wonder which bike is it. Is Luna still seen?

Ever remember that LML also launched a set of bike that included LML GF and few more?
How about Hero Puch? Once a hot favourite, it is now almost extinct.

Though TVS is a common name, remember how many versions of Scooty are available on the road today? Right from the start, there were continuous modifications to the model. Same goes with Victor, Fiero, Fiero F2, Fiero FX and now the story continues with Apache.

For Bajaj, there was a light weight scooterette called Sunny – which had Sachin Tendulakar advertising for it with the “teen machine” campaign. CT 100, Platina, Discover, and even Pulsar have gone continuous and complete modifications.

Nothing can be a fool proof project plan forever. Managers need to close down the projects that result in failure, but they end up doing it too late. They can also make changes to the project plan mid-way, like the constant upgradations that have happened in the vehicles of TVS or Bajaj, but still nothing is secure. The same MD, Rahul Bajaj, now says that by 2010, there will be no bike on the road which will be less than 150 CC. He is actually trying to make way for the coming projects that bajaj has invested in. Not necessarily what may be the future. Windows launched XP, and then there was a ad saying “Still with Windows 98?”. They were trying to create room for the new versions, so that people can buy or upgrade and company can earn profit. However, the fact is that in countries like India, Windows 98 is still working. Majority of the cyber cafes still run windows 98.

In the next article, I’ll talk about the mathematics that is involved when analyzing a project. Please come again tomorrow :- )

Please read the comments and post your views and queries in the comments section which helps in open discussion and avoids duplicity of questions.

You may be interested in reading my previous articles. Here is the link to Table of Contents in a chronological order.

Wednesday, 29 August 2007

Mutual Fund commission related feedback to SEBI

Bhupesh has left an important piece of information regarding the feedback from individual investors to SEBI, for its proposal on waiving off the entry load charges and distribution costs if mutual fund units are directly bought by the investor from the fund management company.

I believe this is an important piece of information and should be placed as an article, because readers usually don’t read all the comments on the past articles.

Thanks Bhupesh for contributing this. Please keep up the good work!


Information from Bhupesh follows:

SEBI is also asking comments from public upon their "Proposal on waiver of load for direct applications in Mutual Fund schemes". Which can be sent @ ruchic@sebi.gov.in.

Probably you should include this information in your article so that people who feel strong in favor of this proposal can send comments to this id.

-----------

I want share what I have sent to SEBI.


-----------
I vote for this proposal.

1) It will help people switching (penalise) under performing schemes.
2) It will promote brokers to provide 2.5% commission worth of services.
3) It will make Mutual Fund more favorable mode of investment.
4) It will improve productivity in distribution/advertising.

If there are some charges even for direct investing with AMC, It
should not be more then ..

1) Lowest % amount charged from an investor.
( e.g. Nil if a Mutual fund house charge nil entry
load for investment over 5 Cr.)

2) Maximum of ( [50% of Normal entry load] or [Entry load - 1%])
( e.g. If normal entry load is 2.5% , ( Max [1.25,
1.5]) = 1.5%)
( e.g. If normal entry load is 1.5% , ( Max [0.75,
0.5]) = 0.75%)


I do my research my self where to invest ? how mutual fund have done
in past and what are the current holding of the fund etc .. . I
always used to feel disheartened while giving 2.5 % commission to
broker for channeling my form to Mutual Fund house. They also do not
provide good service of collecting redemption slip.
-----

End of Info from Bhupesh

You may be interested in reading my previous articles. Here is the link to Table of Contents in a chronological order.

Mutual Funds increase exit loads

Some more bad news for the mutual fund investors – major mutual funds are hiking the exit loads on the most popular funds. The proposal from SEBI regarding slashing the entry load has just caused a panic in the mutual fund industry. Mutual Funds have now revised the load structure at the exit point.

As per the news:
Reliance Mutual Fund, Birla Sunlife Mutual Fund and Franklin Templeton Mutual Fund have increased the exit load in as many as six of their equity schemes.

Exit load is the amount of commission you have to pay when you decide to take your money back from the mutual fund you have invested in. For an example, if you invested 10,000 in a mutual fund, and after 3 years it has grown to 12,000 and you decide to take back your money at these levels, you will have to pay exit load on your maturity money. If the exit load is 2%, then 2% of 12,000 = 240 Rs. will be deducted from your maturity money of 12,000 and you will receive only 11,760 as the final amount.

Exit load is typically the 'desirable' kind of load, as mentioned by the fund industry “experts”. They claim that EXIT LOAD acts as a ‘restriction’ to the MF investors, and high exit loads will force the investors to keep the money invested in the fund for long term.

Now think about this: You give your money to mutual fund managers, they invest your money (basically gamble on random things called stocks), they don’t promise you any returns for sure, they take the charges from you for you giving them your money (sometimes annually, sometimes monthly) and now, they want to increase the charges so as to force you not to take back YOUR money from them.

Sometimes, the reasoning stated by the so-called investment industry experts just makes me believe that it is really a world full of monkeys.

Investments are made with the point of view of getting financial freedom. Why and how can a fund manager dictate to me about how and when should I enter and exit in his fund (causing monetary losses in terms of loads), is something that I cannot digest.

I am getting a feeling that even if SEBI’s proposal of slashing the entry load goes through and is enforced, the mutual fund industry will end up coming up with some or the other fancy nomenclature for taking commission from the investor in the name of professional money management.

Prasad has rightly left a comment on my previous post on SEBI’s proposal, mentioning that he has a SIP plan for investing in a scheme. The SIP investment is automatically done through ECS or Electronic clearing system. So though the broker or agent is not involved in the process at all, he still ends up paying the “distribution commission”.

Considering all these (possible) developments and problems, the only way out for the investor is to keep away from the Mutual Funds. Customer is the king! If the majority of the customers decide to say no to a product, there is no way it can be sold. Filing a lawsuit or PIL in the court may take ages for things to get resolved. Best way for people who want to have efficient investment and better money management is to say no to such products, if they believe that these products are doing no good to their money. Be that product be Mutual Fund, Insurance Policy, ULIP, Index Fund or ETF. Each time I exit from a product after I discover that it is not good, I make sure that I write a letter to the company concerned and clearly state the reason why I am exiting from the product. I also send a copy of that letter to SEBI/IRDA or other regulatory authorities. I know that it is something like wasting time, effort and energy, but I don’t see anything wrong in letting people and authorities know what I believe if I have a genuine reason and data to prove my point.

I know readers are desperately waiting for my articles on Derivatives. I want to borrow some more time because explaining derivatives require a lot of figures and diagrams. Preparing them on a computer is a tough task. My job does not allow me to prepare articles fulltime. I’ll start posting the articles once I have am ready with the minimal set to begin with.

Please read the comments and post your views and queries in the comments section which helps in open discussion and avoids duplicity of questions.

You may be interested in reading my previous articles. Here is the link to Table of Contents in a chronological order.

Monday, 27 August 2007

Mutual Funds –Distribution Cost Cutoff suggestion

A more recent and POSITIVE development that has taken place is in the mutual fund industry. SEBI has offered a suggestion to all the mutual fund houses that they should insist on selling the mutual funds directly to the public, instead of going through distributors or better known as “agents”.

SEBI suggests that Mutual Funds charge the customers with almost 2.25% charges in the name of Distribution Costs. This charge is used to pay to the various distributors and agents who help the mutual fund company to sell mutual fund products to the common public. SEBI suggests that Mutual Funds and asset management companies should insist on selling the units directly to the customer through the online website or advising potential customers to buy it from them by visiting their office. SEBI’s suggestion says that the 2.25% charge should NOT be taken from such customers, who are buying the mutual fund products directly from the company, either online or by visiting their office, as there are no agents or distributors involved. Distribution Charge should be taken only from customers who buy through a distributor or an agent.

Here are some facts about the distributor and agent business in India for selling of such financial products:
• 98% of the money for sale of any Mutual Fund or ULIP scheme is collected through distributors and agents
• That means only 2% of the customers actually buy the product directly from the company
• 2% of the above customers are the ones which are themselves other mutual funds or investment firms who invest into a particular product in big amounts and hence save on charges by directly buying it from the asset management company or fund house

No wonder that the entire mutual fund industry has criticized this suggestion from SEBI in one voice. If they adopt to the suggestion from SEBI, it would mean that the distributors will loose the business within no time. More and more of the customers are now using online transactions for banking and trading. They can as well do the same for buying mutual funds.

The distributors are giving the following reason for not liking the idea from SEBI: “since 98% of the business is routed through distributors and agents, the elimination of distribution cost will mean that mutual funds will not get enough customers. This will hamper the investment business in India”

However, the fact is that the investment business in India will grow better and more number of investors will start considering investing in Mutual Funds, if the administrative charges and commissions are reduced. People like me, who are averse to mutual fund investments because a significant portion of money goes into commissions, as explained in my article: Should you trust your mutual fund manager?, will also start considering investmenting in mutual funds.

The above statement from distributors is nothing but a useless reason because they will be out of business very soon.

On the other hand, the fund managers and mutual fund companies dislike the idea because of the following reason: “We will have to invest heavily on having online system to buy and redeem mutual funds and other products. Moreover, we will have to hire and train our staff who could talk and sell to the customers directly. Having it through the distributors helps manage things better”.

Again, yet another vague reason. Almost all of the mutual fund companies have a toll-free number where one can call and get all the details of the mutual fund or ULIP products. Some of the fund houses even allow you to buy the fund units over the telephone, where your call is recorded and transaction details entered into the system. For e.g., I bought my overseas travel insurance policy over the telephone. If the company can have a few people answer the questions of customers on the phone and some even make them buy the products on the phone, why cant the same team be extended to cut distribution cost and help save the investors money and offer them better returns?
Coming to managing online systems, it is also a fact that all the details of customers and agents are managed using online systems only. There is no paperwork actually involved at the company level. Yet, the companies are quoting this vague reason.

The fact is that the heavy charges being taken in the name of distribution costs are not really used in distribution cost. It’s all disguised and inflated figure. Majority of the commission and cost is pocketed at various levels by people in the supply chain, rest is spent on advertising. If you really look at it, then distribution simply involves filling up a paper form, taking the customer’s signature on it and then sending the policy or fund document by post to the customer. I see no reason why someone investing 100,000 in a mutual fund should end up paying 2.25% or 2250 Rs. in the name of distribution cost. Do you think it takes 2250 Rs to fill up a paper application and send the unit document by post to the customer? OR is it justified for the hopeless level of (misguiding) advices that are given to the customer to buy the fund units?

Not sure how far SEBI can take this suggestion. This is India; there are loads of bureaucratic hurdles in implementing anything that is GOOD for the common men. One can only hope that the suggestion from SEBI finds its way to actually being implemented.

Please read the comments and post your views and queries in the comments section which helps in open discussion and avoids duplicity of questions.

You may be interested in reading my previous articles. Here is the link to Table of Contents in a chronological order.

Thursday, 23 August 2007

Reliance Salary Advantage Fund: Another trap

Yesterday, I saw the promotion of Reliance Salary advantage fund on one of the leading business news channels.

Here is the summary of the offer:

You get salary each month. They advice you to set aside your monthly expenses and other payments that you need to make (like EMI, etc.).
Put the remaining money in Reliance Salary advantage fund.
The money that you put is invested in so called low-risk instruments, which are again mutual funds of reliance like Reliance Liquid Fund.
Their past performance shows that they have managed to get around 6% returns on annual basis.




Although at the end of the table, they do mention that “Past performance may not sustained in future” :- ) Even for a mere 6% past performance annually that too from 1995, they cannot guarantee to sustain it, and they call it salary advantage fund.
You get an ATM cum debit card that you can use to withdraw money anytime. The condition is that in a month, only 1 transaction is free, that too only at HDFC bank ATM. They have not mentioned anything about the charges that you may have to pay for withdrawing money from other ATMs or making more than 1 withdrawal in a month.
Though it is said to be like a liquid bank account, you can withdraw only upto 50% of your invested money – not more than that.
Another disadvantage is that though it is like a bank account, it cannot be used to issue cheques or EMI payments.

One more ambiguity is that the reliance website claims that there are no entry/exit loads; while report on CNBC mentioned that there is a 2.25% entry load. God knows what the truth is. If there is an entry load, reduce it from 6%, you will end up only with 6-2.25% = 3.75% - even less than what is offered by bank account.

There is no mention of the dates for which the investment will be considered for earning interest (like minimum balance between 5th and last date of the month). Such basic things are expected from a newly launched instrument.

The promotion on CNBC sited a “salaried” person, wearing a tie and formal shirt, happily mentioning how satisfied he is with the Reliance salary advantage fund.
-He mentioned that he is assured of 6% returns, as the past performance of the fund has been almost 6%. He is assured based upon the past performance, but the company offering the service is not assured for the returns in the future (as mentioned on their website)
-What has the markets done in last 12 years? Were they limited only to 6% returns? Even the returns from bonds were more that 8%. Probably the salaried person doesn’t know OR he was paid to speak only a few limited sentences for promotion.
-He also mentioned that 6% is better than 3.5% or 4% of what the banks offer. How about the guarantee that the bank gives and uncertainty this fund has?

Now compare it with a bank account or Fixed deposit account. My bank offers me 6% interest rate just for a deposit of more than 3 months. The return is GUARANTEED. If I keep the money for just more than 1 year, I am assured a GUARANTEED return of 9.5% in my FD. Should I still go with reliance salary advantage or should I visit my bank branch or login to internet banking for opening an online FD account?

In essence, this scheme is nothing but another way of presenting a new instrument or service, which is actually not worth it. Somehow, I am now also loosing the trust on the business news channels, about the way they are presenting such things. The promotion appeared to be like a news item – while it was actually an ad. It’s all about promotion and money making business. Let’s be keen on learning about calculating the real numbers, instead of jumping in on any advertisement or advice from a promotional scheme.

This is the official website of reliance salary advantage fund. (Opens in a new window)

Please read the comments and post your views and queries in the comments section which helps in open discussion and avoids duplicity of questions.

You may be interested in reading my previous articles. Here is the link to Table of Contents in a chronological order.

Monday, 13 August 2007

Stock Picking Skills: How to select between 2 stocks? – Part I

This article is a bit off the track, as till now I’ve been talking about NOT to directly invest in stocks :- ) But this blog is for information and knowledge purpose, so let’s see what should be kept in mind when selecting between 2 stocks.

Analysis of any stock selection technique falls into 2 categories:
• Technical Analysis
• Fundamental Analysis

Technical Analysis:
Almost all of us have bought stocks, sometimes or the other in our life – that’s the reason you are reading this blog :- )

So how did you decide to buy it? Well, some of us started by applying for stocks through IPO. Rest of us started looking at the charts as the one presented below.

I started my stock trading business by looking at charts. (This chart is borrowed from Yahoo Finance)



The above chart is for a 5 day period of Reliance. It is showing a downward trend. Hence, I, as a novice trader, believe that whatever is coming down today should go up after some time, so I go ahead and buy this stock. The biggest assumption that I make while buying this stock is “Going down followed by coming up” concept. The problem is that it may not be true, in the short term, in the long term or to talk about the extreme case, the company may even go bankrupt (as happened with the US Subprime mortgage mentioned in my previous article)

This, and any other type of analysis which is based upon trend, patterns and charts, is known as technical analysis. In the case mentioned above, we are going “against the trend”, believing the concept whatever goes down comes up. Opposite to this is what is known as the momentum strategy or Go with the trend strategy: Whatever goes down continues to go down and whatever goes up continues to go up (atleast in short term trading and mid term trading). A typical example of this is IFCI – over the past few months, this stock has risen consistently from the level of 12 Rs. to 65 Rs.

There is some evidence of both these strategies working properly, but without any guarantee. Usually, the opposing strategy works for long term – when we look at investments for long tenures like ALEAST 3 to 4 years. The momentum strategy is found to work in the short term, when the investment horizon is in months, upto a maximum of 3 months (like IFCI).

However, the success rate for both these strategies is found to be around 50% only – meaning it is nothing better than placing a bet. The reason is that within an ocean of stocks and mutual funds, which stock or MF would an investor choose and which theory he will apply to which stock - is the question that makes this theory a failure. Applying long terms strategy to the so-called bluechip stocks or momentum strategy to the midcap stocks, nothing has a success rate better than 50% - as calculated on historical data. Take the transaction costs and brokerage amounts in consideration, and the success rate will come down further.

A simple example that I can quote here is about the last 6 years of Bull Run in the Indian stock markets. So many small cap stocks have become mid caps, while so many mid caps have been promoted to large caps. Applying momentum strategy to any of them for just 2 to 3 months would have been a failure, as you would have lost on the long run gains. Similarly, the stocks like Pieco, Mukund Iron, Premier, etc. which were once a part of Index, no longer exists. Applying long term strategy for this would have been another case of loosing strategy.


Continue to Part II of this article

(3) Stock Picking Skills: How to select between 2 stocks? – Part III

This is part III of the article Stock Picking Skills: How to select between 2 stocks? – Part I. Please read the article from the first part before continuing with this one.

However, you should look at all the above points listed as First, second and so on. First assumption: Identify the value and source of investment, this itself is a tough task. How can one get accurate information about a company’s projects and the revenues its going to generate. Second, everything should go on schedule – may be possible, but not in majority of cases. Third, again another assumption, how can one get details of how much a project will generate. Fourth, calculating the PV from inaccurate FV – biggest problem is the rate of interest.
Most important – we have assumed only 1 single project. How about a stock like reliance, which has business in so many sectors – chemicals, refining, exploration, petroleum, textile, retails stores, etc. How can one estimate projects in so many different sectors, how about the time horizon of the different projects, how about the investments made in overseas countries, and the forex currency fluctuations?
The list is endless and all we end up with DCF is high level of error-prone method.


Ultimately, the Fundamental Analysis also works in only 2 cases:
1. When you are lucky and your predictions turn out to be correct
2. When you have insider information about the company (which is illegal)

Hence, we as common investors, either working as salaried professionals or running our own shops and businesses, cannot benefit from the hi-fi terms and calculations required in fundamental analysis.

Whether we follow the technical analysis or fundamental analysis, all that is required for us is luck. If we are lucky, our stock selection even in penny stocks will turn out to be profitable. If we are unlucky, our investment even in so called bluechip companies will end up in a loss, even in long run. Your mutual fund manager cannot do anything better – instead you end up paying commission to him.

These were the 2 basic analysis methods that are commonly used not only by individuals, but also by fund managers and asset management companies. In the next article, I’ll explain one of the most efficient valuation criteria, which will give some insight on stock selection. Please note that nothing is foolproof in this world of finance. The moment a method or strategy is identified as fool-proof, everyone starts following that and ultimately it fails. A simple example on similar lines: If it is known that Infosys will give 50% return in one year, everyone will be willing to buy Infy. There will be only buyers and no sellers. If a seller appears, he will be willing to sell Infy stock at a price which is already having 50% value added in it. Hence, your buy order will not get executed. If it does, it will be at a price that automatically has this value reflected into the price you pay for getting your investments.

Please visit this blog tomorrow for a better quantitative criteria for stock selection.

Do post your questions in the comments section, in case you have any.

Keep visiting this blog for further content.

Please read the comments and post your views and queries in the comments section which helps in open discussion and avoid duplicity of questions.

You may be interested in reading my previous articles. Here is the link to Table of Contents in a chronological order.

If you've liked this article – do visit the sponsors.

Thursday, 9 August 2007

Stock Market pricing and fluctuations: Part I

Over the last 1 week, we have seen high level of volatility in the stock markets across the globe. Not only the US stock market, but stock markets across the globe have been seeing regular downfalls. Yesterday, a major French Bank named BNP Paribas has closed 3 of its mutual funds costing a loss of a staggering 2.2 billion dollars. While last week, Australia based Macquerie bank has informed its fund holders that there may a minimum of 25% loss on their portfolio. What is the reason for all this? Let me attempt to present a layman’s view on this.

There is a company called Subprime mortgage and it is having business in the US. The business of this company is to offer housing loans to individuals and businesses, similar to what we know as home loans offered by any bank. The company is big in size and has presence not only in US, but also in other countries as well. However, the problem started with its US based business only.

The company offers loans for buying or renting property in the US, same like any bank will offer home loan in India. It has been a hot favourite house loan company in US since a long time, but the recent exposures have resulted in its downfall. The problem started just around 10 days back, when the company discovered that majority of the individuals and organizations, to whom it has granted loans, are not in the state to repay their loans.
It takes decades for a company to build up its reputation; it takes less than an hour for the company to loose its creditworthiness. The moment these shortfalls where discovered, the company was in deep trouble. Not only the investors panicked, the entire real estate and house loan came under immense pressure. The wave effect caused the bearish mood to spread to other segments of the market as well and within a matter of few days, the entire US market came down and is still going down.

The problem did not stop there. US based Investment Company called Bear Sterns, which runs hedge funds, had significant exposure to the real estate market in US. The result, Bear Sterns funds and other funds in US went down in value. Since Bear Sterns is a finance company, the effect lead to downfall in prices of the financial sector as well, because other financial companies in US are also having investments in real estate market. Also, home loan is directly linked to banking and financial services sector. One went down, other also felt the pinch.

Continue to Part II of this article

Stock Market pricing and fluctuations: Part II


This is part II of the article Stock Market pricing and fluctuations: Part I. Please read the first part before proceeding with this one.

“Vasudhev Kutumbakum” or the “World is a global village” factor cannot be left behind. So Australia based Macquerie Bank which had big investment in US real estate market, lost heavily on its investments. Therefore, it has to announce to its investors that the losses in the funds may be more than 25%.

The next turn was for the European markets. BNP Paribas, one of the leading banks of France, yesterday declared that it is closing 3 of its funds, as these funds have lost significant value due to losses in US markets. The total value at the time of closing these funds was a staggering 2.2 billion dollars. What is the status of the investors who have invested in the funds of Bear Sterns, Macquerie Bank or BNP Paribas? I have no comments to make, but only sympathies for them.

Who’s next on the list? Predictions are that China will be next one to be affected by this contagious decease of global downfall. The reason is that the Chinese investment companies too have invested heavily in US. Same may be the case with other countries like Germany, UK, etc.

Coming to India, it is impossible that India is not affected by US happenings. Yesterday Nifty lost 1.5%, today it is down a further more than 2%. Nobody knows how long will this continue.

So what do we see here? Let’s look at this from the very beginning. ONE SINGLE company in US has problems. The final result: Stock Markets ACROSS THE GLOBE collapse, big banks shut down their funds, investors left at the mercy of the divine because their “Investments were subject to MARKET RISKS”.

Can anyone predict such a thing? Who would believe that the problems will ONE SINGLE company can affect the stock prices across the globe? But it has happened!

Most of you may be reading financial newspapers like the Wall street journal, financial times or economic times. These papers are full of quarterly company report, publishing their balance sheets. Fund managers and researchers look at these results, trying to analyze the performance of the company and base their investment decisions on these figures presented. However, one important thing to note is that the reports are printed with a big word “UNAUDITED”. What it means – the results are prepared internally by the company, and there have been no audit, or verification, by an external company or agency. And this is what causes problems. It is always possible to question to results of a publicly listed company, but by the time the audit is over or the truth comes out, the damage is already done.

Subprime mortgage case is just a typical example of how stock market investments can collapse within a matter of just few hours. It takes decades for building businesses and reputation; it hardly takes a few minutes for it to collapse completely. You may not be having any investment in subprime mortgage – your investments may be only in Indian mutual funds and Indian stocks. Same goes for the Australian or French investors. But just because of one company collapsing somewhere in another country, losses are made by people across the globe.

At the time of writing this article, the nifty has gone down by more than 3%. DowJones situation is more pathetic. No body knows how long will this position continue. CNBC yesterday even quoted this situation as “Bubble 2.0”, which indicated that this may be a second version of what we have seen as internet bubble burst in 2000-2001. Personally, it seems to be an extreme case to me.

This article was aimed at presenting the sequence or chain reaction that is going on in the world stock markets. How a single company can result in the collapse of the entire world market. Take risk in equities because they have proved to be good investments over long term, but set a target when you get into an investment - and exit when the target is achieved.

Keep visiting this blog for further content.

Please read the comments and post your views and queries in the comments section which helps in open discussion and avoid duplicity of questions.

You may be interested in reading my previous articles. Here is the link to Table of Contents in a chronological order.

Monday, 6 August 2007

Contra Funds: An Introduction to Contra Funds - Part I

JM Financials have recently come out with a Contra fund named JM Contra fund. But what exactly are these contra funds and how do they work? Do they give a better investment option as compared to any other normal fund? Let’s discuss the answer to these questions in this article.

Contra stands for contrarian and is supposed to be the opposite of value investing.

The contrarian approach is said to involve a lot more complex stock picking and investment process. What contrarian fund management approach stresses is as follows:

Contrarian approach is more to do with identifying the neglected stocks, which may be undervalued today, but promise a high growth potential in the long run. These stocks are expected to be bought cheaper today, as they may be ‘neglected’ by the market in the short run resulting in low prices, but may turn out to be the winners in the long run. The fund manager and analysts of a contra fund claim that they can identify such stocks – which are available at dirt cheap prices today as they are neglected by the market in the short perspective. They claim that by identifying such stocks and investing in them today, they are able to capitalize upon the market valuation and benefit from the long term investment horizon when these stocks become valuable, as the market gradually identifies their potential.

These funds believe that the best time to build up a portfolio is when there is an unwarranted risk aversion in the market coupled with high pessimism, and they aim to exit from the market when markets or stocks are heated up. In essence, these funds take “opposing” or “contrarian” positions with respect to the market estimates and valuation and aim to benefit from them.

JM Fund also claims the same: “JM Contra Fund would follow this simple rule in making investments into specific sectors, stocks or segments. It will aim to have a first mover advantage by investing into 'out of favour' sectors/stocks.Thus increasing out performance prospects. It would incubate stocks for a while before they find favour with the rest of the market. It would also proactively identify new investment themes and build up strong positions before a majority of investors do. JM Contra Fund would endeavor to generate steady returns with low volatility”

They also give justification for coming up with timing of launch of the Contra fund now: “During the past one year we have seen markets being excessively volatile resulting in high risk aversion among investors. Sharp downsides seen in the market on the back of uncertainties in global events, economic growth, government policy etc. have resulted in extreme skepticism in the market. All such events are converging today, creating huge opportunity for generating future returns. Therefore the current environment is apt for contrarian investment.”

The above approach of contra fund investment is opposite to the normally followed approach in mutual fund – often termed as value investing. Value investing also involves doing research and coming up with stock recommendations, but it is usually done for stocks that are well established in the market (like so called blue-chip stocks) or the stocks that have started to prove their value by posting good results (like the mid-cap stocks).

Continue to Part II of this article

2-Contra Funds: An Introduction to Contra Funds-Part II

This is part II of the article Contra Funds: An Introduction to Contra Funds

. Please read the first part before proceeding with this one.

However, Contra fund investment style does not necessarily guarantee any sure shot returns. The best way to defy a claim is to attack the underlying assumptions of that claim. For a contra fund, the most important underlying assumption is that the fund manager and research analysts claim to identify such undervalued low price stocks. Is it really possible for anyone to identify such stocks? Well, not at all. As I’ve proved in my previous articles: Stock Picking: Good Company v/s Bad Company, Equity research, Analysis & the recommendations and The Stock Trading Markets: Traders and Market Makers, there is no way one can identify any specific stocks with the publicly available information. The only way one can do so is if he is LUCKY or has insider information about a company. However, trading on insider information is illegal.

A simple way to prove that contrarian approach of fund management may not work is with the huge size of the market. As I’ve proved in the previous articles, markets are huge and people are just waiting for profit booking opportunities. Fund managers have to deal with big amount of money, for e.g. recently, Reliance mutual fund was able to gather almost 5900 crore Rs. from the market. When the fund manager has to manage a big amount of money like this, he has to invest by buying big no. of stocks in huge quantity. The moment a fund manager places an order for buying a particular stock, the market senses it and immediately the prices start to rise. It is possible that an initial portion of the order gets executed at a lower price, but majority of the order gets executed at a higher price. Here’s a simple example:

A MF manager places order to buy 20 Lakh shares of XYZ Company currently trading at a price of 500 Rs. It is possible that first 1 lakh shares are bought at 500 Rs., but soon the market senses that there is a big demand (19 lakh shares) for XYZ shares and the price starts to go up. So the remaining order of 19 lakh shares is fulfilled at a much higher price and the total average price that is paid for the entire order is huge. A practical way to prove this is that we often here that ABC stock has gone up by 5-10% today and was the main winner for today trading. The reason for the stock price of a particular stock to shoot up so much is either it has some major profitable news (great income reporting, bagging order worth billions, a new discovery or something similar) or an MF manager buying this stock in big nos. causing the prices to go up. Hence, ultimately the market, and not the MF manager decides the price of the stock that he purchases and he ends up paying the market price. The profitable opportunity is lost there itself. If any such opportunity exists, it exists only in the long run, that too based on the assumption that the business will sustain, it will not have competition, it will be profitable and similar loads of conditions.

Continue to Part III of this article


Copyright Information:
© http://invest-n-trade.blogspot.com
Please see Our Copy Right Policy. All the articles, posts and other materials on this website/blog are copyrighted to the owners of this portal. The content should NOT to be reproduced on any other website or through other medium, without the author's AND owners' permission.

DISCLAIMER: Before using this site, you agree to the Disclaimer.

About UsAdvertise with UsCopyRight Policy & Fair Use GuidePrivacy PolicyDisclaimer