Showing posts with label Financial Models. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Financial Models. Show all posts

Wednesday, 23 January 2008

Mark to market (MTM) factor & Stock Market Fall Effects

There has been some respite for the traders and investors yesterday. From the lows of 4500, the stock market (Nifty) has again managed to climb back to 5200 levels.

However, in the process of this drastic transition, where the Nifty started declining from the high level of 6200 to the lows of 4500, many investors and traders have lost their capital. Even though the Nifty is again going to climb back, the traders and investors have lost their money because some sell stock orders were executed at the lowest of the low values.

Majority of that has been attributed to the MTM effect or the Mark To Market Factor. In this article, I’ll explain how the MTM effect works. What is Mark to Market and how does that affect a trader’s position. I will also touch upon the associated things – Margin call requirements.

Some brokers like ICICIdirect have a strict requirement that you MUST have the entire money in your trading account, before you can buy any shares through them. So if I want to buy shares worth 10,000 then I must have 10,000 already deposited in my ICICI account and from there I should allocate that 10,000 for trading purpose. Then and only then I will be allowed to buy shares or buy stocks as per my stock picks.

However, majority of the brokers, like IL&FS, etc. do NOT require the entire amount to be deposited with them. Hence, if I have a brokerage account with IL&FS, Motilal Oswal or Angel broking (just for an example), then I can place my buy stocks order even without having a penny in my account. So if I wish to buy shares worth 100,000, I just place a call to my IL&FS broker and he places the order for me in the exchange. If it gets executed, due to T+3 settlement cycle (or T+1 in the US stock markets or T+3 in UK stock markets), I have 3 days time to provide the required money to my broker. Due to T+3 cycle, the shares will come to my demat account only on the 3rd day and the cash should go from my account only on the 3rd day. Hence, that gives me a leveraged position for 3 days.

There can be other brokerage firms which require a percentage of money to be kept with them initially. Say 20%. So if I want to place an order of 100,000, then I should initially have 20,000 with the broker. Ultimately, it depends upon the criteria set by the broker you are dealing with.

So I place the order, I pay the broker in (or within) 3 days time and I get the shares. All fair and good. But there can be a problem.

Remember you will be required to sign at as many as 45 different places on a brokerage account document to open a trading account? There are certain conditions mentioned in that which we obviously ignore and take for granted.

Every brokerage firm has a Risk management division. This division decides the amount of risk they can bear and depending upon that they decide the limit upto which the client’s positions can be leveraged.

However, there is a requirement for the brokers to comply with the MTM or Mark to market factor. The MTM factor means that for all leveraged positions, the broker will be required to have cash, in case the market price of the stock starts falling down.

Let’s take an example. Suppose Microsoft is trading at $20. Due to some problems, the stock price starts to go down. There may be a set limit of providing extra cash to cover for positions if the stock price falls by say 25%. So if the stock price of Microsoft touches $15 (25% below), then the brokers (and ultimately their clients) who are holding positions in Microsoft in this leveraged style (without depositing the entire buy amount), will be required to pay the money to cover their losses in the leveraged positions.

So in the last 2-3 days, the same situation was happening in the Indian markets. Traders and investors had such leveraged positions with their brokers. As the stock prices started to tumble downwards, the brokers were required (as per their risk management divisions) to cover for the losses in the leveraged positions due to stock price meltdown. Remember, a broker is only an intermediary in the trading process. The actual liability lies with the trader or investor or the client who is trading. Hence, the broker, on behalf of the clients, was required to have cash for the leveraged stock positions.

Continue to Part 2: How Margin calls are placed and what is required?

Margin Calls and Requirements for Mark To Market (MTM)

This is part 2 of the article: Mark to market (MTM) factor & Stock Market Fall Effects-1. Please read the first part before continuing with this one.

Usually, when such a thing happens, the brokers call the client on the phone individually and give them a deadline (usually 12 to 24 hours) to furnish the required money for MTM. But unfortunately, due to the regulations, the brokers cannot accept cash. All transactions should happen in paper or electronic form (cheque, demand draft or online transfer). Hence, though the brokers raised to margin calls, though the clients deposited the cheques with the brokers, the clearing time of 24 hrs to 3 days ensured that money did not reach the broker’s account within the given time limit. Hence, with lack of required cash, the brokers were forced to meet up the MTM requirement by selling stocks.

Now cheques can treated as a guarantee. But there is a fear that cheque may bounce due to lack of money in the clients account. Hence, the brokers need the cheque to be really encashed. Ultimately, they were left with no solution but to sell the shares at the lowest of the low prices for their clients.

Finally, it was the clients who lost. They may have bought the shares at a price of 100. The price starts to fall down, reaches 75, the broker raises a MTM margin call. Though the clients may have money to furnish for the margin requirements, the problem with the clearing mechanism forces the broker to cover for the losses by selling stocks. This panic and forceful selling for MTM further deteriorated the stock prices and they went for a tailspin.

So even if the client has sufficient money, he may have to suffer the loss. Even if he had the capacity to withstand the bear hug, he may have been forced to book the losses because of the MTM and margin requirements.

Hence, it becomes extremely important to discipline your trading activities and your leveraged positions. It sounds good when the broker tells you that you don’t need to have money ready when you place the order, and you can furnish the money within 3 days time for T+3 settlement cycle. You feel happy that your money can earn interest in the bank and there is no need to keep it idle with the broker if you don’t trade.

However, all that money management and interest earnings tactics and trading strategies go off the fly in a split second, when the markets tumble, like the way they have in the past 3-4 days. It therefore becomes extremely important to understand the risk management requirements of the brokers. It is better to Select a broker after proper research & keep the money with a quality broker having strict requirements for advance deposit, rather than going for a cheap and lousy brokerage house giving all kinds of leverages to the clients. What you may not save in the interest part, much more than that you can loose in the MTM and Margin calls requirement. Remember, the more regulations and restrictions you face, the better you are shielded when you are hit by a big loss.

Yesterday I saw on CNBC webcast, people fought with the employees at brokerage firms due to their trades being cut-off for margin calls and MTM requirements. They were forced to book losses. Another piece of news took to the jewelry stores or pawn brokers. People were found selling their gold ornaments and gold bars or keeping them on mortgage to get some cash to suffice for the margin requirements. Ignorance, lack of knowledge about regulations (set by market as well as the brokers), and taking things for granted will force you to learn the things in a costly way. Learn it before jumping in and play it safe!
Table of Contents

Monday, 7 January 2008

Stock Market Trading Strategies-1

Andy has left a nice comment on my previous post – Andy wants to beat the bank rate!

Actually, that is one of the very good targets to achieve. People have different targets – some like Mutual Fund mangers go after the market index they are tracking, and they attempt to beat it. Some traders try to beat the bank Fixed deposit rate (as Andy is attempting to do), some have individual targets fixed for themselves, depending upon what they want to achieve, and the rest just don’t know what to do. Unfortunately, majority of us fall in the last category – we just don’t know how much we want to achieve and in how long horizon.

In stocks trading business of selling and buying stocks, one of the things that’s always good to achieve is to have knowledge about what you want and in what time period. If we have certainty in our ambitions, then 50% of our work is done. If we don’t have any certainty in what we want to achieve, we are already half way defeated. It’s easy to see our stock price going up by 50%, but having no target in mind means we have no clue about how long should I wait for and how much return can I expect from this stock. Even if we have that in our minds, we cannot be sure when this target will be achieved.

Anyways, traders are traders. It is commonly observed that people get fascinated about the rise they see in the stocks they are holding, they keep on holding the stock for long but uncertain time – just to observe that one fine day their rising stocks have taken a U-turn and started going down. They get fascinated with their holdings, build up strong belief that the stock would once again rise and hold it. Ultimately, no one has any clue on what they want to achieve.

As stated earlier, half the problem is solved if we get out of our stock holding fantasies and affections that we develop with our holding shares. If you are a long term investor, define to yourself what long term is. If you are a short term trader, decide what short term for you is. Nobody other than you can help you!

Andy has raised a valid point and I would say it is a very good strategy for any trader to have an aim to beat the bank rate in a year. The reason – banks rates are, generally, always positive, while the return from equities or stock trading, even index based ETF may turn out to be negative. Hence, suppose in the next year the index like Nifty goes down by 20%, then your ETF investment will also go down by 20% or so. However, if you manage to keep up your trading activities and follow you goals religiously to beat the bank rate of 10%, then you will be outperforming the markets by 30%. Even fund managers fail to do so, traders aspire to do so consistently – some fail, some succeed.

On the other side, instead of going down, if the markets go up by 20% and you are still with a little more than 10% of your returns beating the bank rate, then you will fall much behind the market.

Continue to Part II of this article

Stock Market Trading Strategies-2

This is part II of the article: Stock Market Trading Strategies-I, please read the first part before proceeding with this part:

Ultimately, it depends upon your psychological biases and targets that you set with the level of certainty. As I’ve explained in my previous post Forex currency trading and Hedging strategies, that hedging is used for eliminating the risk and to achieve a certainty in the future prices. So if you loose on a significant bull run while you are in a hedged position, you should not repent because your purpose for hedging was to eliminate the risk and achieve the desired level of certainity in your profits.

Same thing goes here as well. If you are happy by beating the bank rate, don’t repent on loosing on a 50% bull run in the market.
One more thing to notice is that you should know how to calculate the profits. That includes deducting the brokerage charges, demat charges, internet charges (if you pay for it), phone calls (if trading by call-n-trade) and basically anything that accrues a cost for your trading activities.

Another aspect of looking at this strategy is effort v/s reward. Is beating the bank rate justified for the amount of time, effort and energy you put in?

We should not forget that the bank rate that we get is effortless and with 100% certainity. You just walk into a bank branch, put in your money with a particular saving scheme in a bank account and walk away without any worries. You come back on the maturity date and happily take away your money plus the interest or return that you’ve earned. Simple and Straightforward.

But is it same for trading stocks with having an aim of beating the bank rate? One cannot quantify the effort you put in stock picking skills, the time you invest in researching the stocks, or refreshing the stock prices webpage for trading on a daily basis. It is difficult to keep track of internet usage or telephone bills. We tend to forget the demat charges and brokerage fee – even if we do so, we do not usually take the time value of discounted cash flows.

Ultimately, this is the randomness that one trader has to fight against. No one can have any control on which way the market goes, which way the stock prices move and how much you can make from your stock picks. Remember that it is not possible to quantify the efforts that you put in while trading, leave apart the brokerage and other charges. No point in beating the bank rate by a mere 1% or 2%; one just has to be lucky to make a significantly high profit than that offered by the bank.

Monday, 17 December 2007

Stock Prices: January Effect on Stock Prices

Continuing further from the first part of this article on January Effect on Stock Prices, here is the second part:

A number of detailed explanations have been suggested for the observed January effect,
but few only the following give a reasonable justification:

• Tax loss selling by investors


Taxes are the biggest concern for traders and investors across the world.
In the US, December is end of tax-year. Hence, at the end of the tax-year, there is wide spread selling of the stocks which have 'lost money' to capture the capital gain, driving down the prices, presumably below true value, in December, and a buying back of the same stocks in January, resulting in the high returns.

Then, there is also a “wash sales rules” which prevents an investor from selling and buying back the same stock within 45 days, and there has to be some substitution among the stocks.
Thus investor X sells stock A and investor Y sells stock B, but when it comes time to buy back the stock, investor X buys stock B and investor Y buys stock A.

It will be interesting to note the same effect happening in the month of March to April for countries like India, where the financial year ends in the month of March. Moreover, there is no such rule like “Wash Sales Rule” in India, so traders can keep on betting on the same stocks again and again.

• A second reasoning is that the January effect is related to institutional trading behavior around the turn of the years. It has been noted, for example, that ratio of buys to sells for institutions drops significantly below average in the days before the turn of the year and picks to above average in the months that follow. However, once again to repeat, it has only been observed historically. There is no guarantee that the same will continue further.

• A third and very important Behavioural Aspect that has been observed is due to Christmas and Holiday Season. Since it is festival and holiday time in the US (and other western countries), people need money for spending – either for buying gifts for their loved ones, making new purchases for self and family, or for going on enjoying the holidays. All this results in huge spending and the investors usually try to take the money out of their investments. Hence there is wide spread selling. This again causes stock prices to tumble just before festive season, i.e. early and mid-December. The same investors will again come back in January for putting in fresh money and starting again, hence the January effect predominates.

Not only for USA, the January effect is prominent for other countries as well. Here is the graph showing the historical returns in the month of January as compared to other months for different countries across the globe.



However, all the observation and data dates back to 1927 and is primarily concerned with USA stock markets. It forms an interesting case for other countries like India because firstly, the Indian financial year is different from the US financial year and secondly, the festive season is in October-November (Diwali/Dusshera). So things may be different for stock markets like India.
However, the Indian stock markets are still dominated by FII and other foreign investments, so this effect can be seen in India too.
We are about to enter January, so one may try his luck if he or she wishes - off course at his own risk ! :-)
Table of Contents

Friday, 14 December 2007

Seasonal Effects on Stock Prices:January Effect


Here is something that might be of great interest to the traders and market-makers who trade on intra-day or weekly basis:

Empirical studies suggest that a variety of seasonal and temporary effects can be observed in the behaviour and movement of stock prices. Among them, the primary ones are:

• The January Effect: Stocks, on average, tend to do much better in January than in any other month of the year.

• The Weekend Effect: Stocks, on average, seem to do much worse on Mondays than on any other day of the week.

• The Mid-day Swoon: Stocks, on average, tend to do much worse in the middle of the trading day than at the beginning and end of the day.

One thing should be noted very well that while these empirical effects are only historical, they atleast provide some basis for traders, However, it is not at all certain whether any of them can be used with 100% accuracy to generate excess profit from stock trading.

In this article, I’ll concentrate only on the January effect and in the later articles, I’ll cover the remaining.

The January Effect in Stock Prices


• Studies of returns in the United States and other major financial stock markets have revealed strong signals in return behavior during different months of the year.
• As observed, Returns in January are significantly higher than returns in any other month of the year. This phenomenon is called the year-end or January effect and it can be traced to the first two weeks in January.

Another interesting observation is that the January effect is found to be much more prominent for small cap stocks or small firms than for larger firms.

As can be observed from the graph of the figure above, the monthly returns in the month of January have been significantly higher. However, the data used dates back to 1927 and hence conclusion can be drawn from the above chart for trading only based upon your risk taking responsibility.

In the next article, let's discuss about the explanations, reasoning and whether and how to benefit from such an effect.
Table of Contents

Wednesday, 5 December 2007

Arbitrage Trading: Example, Introduction, Overview-1

In this article, I will attempt to introduce the concept of “Arbitrage Trading”

What is Arbitrage Trading? How does arbitrage trading works? How to make profit from Arbitrage Trading? What are the risks with Arbitrage Trading?

Arbitrage trading literally means “Risk Free Profit” . A similar concept can be extended as “Free Lunch” or “Free Money Making Machine”.
Across the globe, traders and market makers attempt to get this risk free profit while attempting to do arbitrage trading.

Let’s take an example:
Let’s say a stock XYZ is listed on 2 stock exchanges: NASDAQ as well as NYSE (Same like Reliance is listed both on NSE and BSE).

So as an arbitrage trader, I attempt to benefit from the stock price difference between the two stock exchanges for the same XYZ stock. Let’s say the XYZ stock is trading at $20 on NASDAQ, and at the same moment, the price at NYSE for XYZ is $20.50. Hence, I spot this price difference, and buy XYZ stock on the exchange where it is available for cheap, and immediately sell it at the exchange where it is costlier.

In the above example, I’ll buy 100 shares of XYZ on NASDAQ with a BUY price of $20 and immediately sell 100 shares at NYSE for $20.5. Hence, in the process (if everything goes well), I make $0.5 per share, or 100 shares * $0.5 = $50 on the trade, within less than a minute.

So, at the end of this exercise, I will have ZERO position in XYZ stocks, i.e. RISK FREE (as I’m not holding anything), and still I make a profit – that’s why RISK FREE PROFIT or ARBITRAGE TRADING.

One of the major reasons for stock prices to move with every single tick of time is because of arbitrage trading. Traders and market makers across the globe keep on continuously buying and selling stocks on one or two exchanges, attempting to get the benefit of price difference. This leads to price change and very high level of volatility in prices of stocks that are traded heavily.

So at the end of the day, if you see a volume of 10 million shares of Reliance stock being traded, then it is possible that a single trader may have bought 1 million shares on NSE and immediately sold them on BSE for a better price – causing a total of 2 million shares to be traded. However, he is having ZERO position at the end.

Interestingly, though traders and market makers across the globe keep on attempting to go for arbitrage trading, they sometimes fail miserably.

The risks involved in Arbitrage trading is no less. One has to simultaneously BUY and SELL.
What if your BUY order gets executed, and your SELL order does not? You end up sitting on a very big number of shares.
Then, what if your SELL order gets executed, but the BUY order does not? At the end of the day, you will be forced to close your position by buying at a higher price – which will result in a big loss.
What if your BUY order for 100 shares was executed, but the SELL order was executed only for 50 shares?

Continue to Part II: How to beat risk in Arbitrage Trading?

Arbitrage Trading: Example, Introduction, Overview-2

This is part II of the article: Arbitrage Trading: Example, Introduction, Overview-I. Please start with this first part before continuing with this one.

A simple way to beat the failure in arbitrage trading is to go for effective capital management and keep on doubling your bets if your buy decision goes wrong. However, there has been no sure shot model through which risk-free profit can be made. Ultimately, Arbitrage Trading is nothing but BETTING.

Computers have been used to directly trade using algorithms, using capital management concepts - yet till date - all these algorithms have resulted in big failures.

Take this case; Royal Dutch SHELL (a Holland based Oil company) is listed on both London stock exchange and Amsterdam stock exchange. As a part of my job, I was attempting to test if arbitrage opportunities exist between LSE and AEX.

There were some problems identified firsthand:
• London is one hour behind Amsterdam, so time difference factor had to be considered for pre market, post market and overlapping market timings.
• LSE trades in Pounds, while AEX trades in Euros, hence tick by tick data for forex should also be taken into consideration

Ultimately, after a long running effort, the algorithm was designed, tested and the back-testing showed that it is resulting in very very profitable results.
All set to go, the model was installed with live data feed and we were hoping that the computer will make billions for us, but within 3 hours it wiped off all our capital. Another few weeks we continued modifying the algorithm and testing with live feed from stock markets – it was profitable sometimes; and equally bad, it was in loss same no. of times.
What was hurting the model was the transaction costs. Unfortunately, we could not generate any realizable profitable gains – contrary to the success on historical data, the model was just not able to understand the market scenario. We kept on testing it over a long period of time, ultimately, it was sent to the “Recycle Bin”.

There has been no model in the history of stock markets which has managed to give a consistent and good Risk free return. That was the reason I’d questioned the Quant based “Lotus India Agile Fund” in my review.

The case of ETF is an interesting one. One of the readers had asked “If ETFs are the best bet in the market, why should anyone sell it?”. The reason is “Arbitrage Trading”.

The organizations which issue ETF’s buy the underlying stocks listed in the indices – that too in big number. Hence, they have a net positive position in terms of stocks. To offload that, they issue (or sell) ETF units, at a slightly higher price. Hence, their position is secure, because they do not have any net position, and yet they make decent profits. Ultimately, they have to keep an eye on Index changes, and consolidate their positions accordingly.

Can we individuals benefit from arbitrage trading?
YES – if you take up a fulltime traders job, and keep a constant eye on every single price change in the market hours. At the same time, you should also have big amount of money to play around with and ability to get wiped off completely. And yes, the LUCK factor – because MARKETS ARE EFFICIENT and RANDOMNESS RULES.

One may try his luck if he wishes

Monday, 3 December 2007

Trading and Investment for beginners

Recently saw the movie “Om Shanti Om”. Not sure how many of you liked it, but to me it was a clear cut example of “How to make a complete mess of a classic movie called Karz”.

Interestingly, every single item of it was copied ditto from the Rishi Kapoor starrer KARZ. Yet, the producer of Karz, Subhash Ghai, appeared in this copied version. Right from Cricket Matches to TV Reality shows, the actor, actress, producer, director, everyone whole heartedly attempted to promote the movie at every stage.

Despite being a ditto copied version, the movie managed to reap profits. Even people like me who are critics and hate such copied attempts, watched the movies in costly multiplexes, spent a big amount of money on tickets, another big amount on costly pop-corns and parking fee at multiplexes, just to discover that the movie is too hopeless.

Even the ever repeated dialogue was copied from the famous book “The Alchemist” – “If you dream of something, the entire universe conspires to attempt to make it meet with you”

Now the producer, director, actor and all knew that the movie is copied – maybe they had the idea of improving the old classic. But the fact is that it was targeted towards the younger generation of audience, who may have not seen the original. People who have seen the original movie would know that the latest one would no where stand in front of the old classic.

The same thing goes on in the financial world. Every month, a new set of young guns start earning. After some time, when they get sufficient money and savings, they start pondering about what to do with it? Shop, Eat, Celebrate? The question finally leads them to the stock market. Everyone believes that they are there to make money, and it is only the risk taking ability that brave hearts like them need to develop, so that their profits keep on increasing.

The agents, like the film promoters, are there to (mis)guide them. They can open demat accounts for them, assist them with their valuable investment advice and keep collecting their brokerage.

If the person is lucky, he makes profit. It usually takes him a long time to discover what is good and if he is in real profit or not. By the time he discovers it, the broker has collected a big amount of profit from him. It is only then this person realizes that the best ways to invest in into index fund or Exchange Traded funds (ETFs), or an alternative is to be LUCKY with you stock picking skills.

Someone asked me in my previous post that if Index funds are the most efficient alternatives, then why is everyone not investing only in Index funds? To understand this, one should understand how the ETF’s and Index funds are brought into the market. Some details are covered in these articles: ETF and this article

The people who are issuing (selling) ETF shares are the ones who are actually buying the shares of the constituent companies. They do it in large numbers, so they get the shares for cheap. They then create the ETF or Index fund units and sell it in the open market for a bit higher price. Since they trade in huge volumes, they make decent profits.

Unfortunately, as long as the newcomers will keep entering the stock markets with their novice level of knowledge, they will continue to be living under the false impression of stock picking skills and money making strategies. In the long run, one can only be lucky or he will later discover that what he has been doing was not worth as compared to the indices.

Be it a movie, or a cricket match or a casino or even betting on horses and dogs (in western countries), the world is full of examples where newcomers join the stream with a hope to make money – but all meet the same fate in the long run. The sooner we realize our luck and limitations, the better!

Thursday, 29 November 2007

Review of Lotus India Agile Fund (Quant Based Fund)

Lotus India Asset Management company has recently launched a so called quant based mutual fund that is aimed at investing in such a fashion that it will eliminate human errors and select the stocks based on a computer generated algorithm.

I liked the punch-line “Eliminate Human Error” and depend upon computer algorithms for stock selection and portfolio churnings.

At last, there is one such fund house that agrees that fund management can contain human errors. Should it mean that other previous funds from Lotus AMC (and other fund houses), are not worth the investor’s trust, as they may be full of human errors?

The fund has the standard rate as per other funds – 2.25% at entry load, 1%, 0.6% and Nil exit load based upon the time you exit after remaining invested in the fund.

As per the details:
Lotus India Asset Management Company Monday launched Quant based scheme, Lotus India AGILE Fund (Alpha Generated from Industry Leaders Fund).

Quant funds operate on the basis of computer generated mathematical models. The investment objective is to generate capital appreciation by investing in a passive portfolio of stocks selected from the industry leaders on the basis of a mathematical model.

The new fund offer priced at Rs 10 per unit.

The fund will invest 90-100 per cent in equity and equity related instruments and 0-10 per cent in debt and money market instruments.

The fund offers two options--Growth and Dividend. The Dividend option offers Dividend Payout and Dividend Re-investment facilities.

Lotus India Agile Fund is an open ended equity scheme that will invest in 11 stocks (9 per cent each) determined by a mathematical model. The portfolio will be reviewed and reset every month.

The fund wants to limit itself to only 11 stocks. Can the algorithm be efficient enough to select the best performing 11 stocks always?

If the fund is so good and (human) error free, then why are there entry and exit loads as any other standard fund? Can the AMC give any guarantee of even 1% returns?

Can a computer really work better in predicting stock prices for the future? Elderly people are now going to cyber-cafes to match the horoscopes of their child with those of their prospective life-partners. All that happens is that crap software like “Kundli” uses stored information and matches the horoscope. Hardly anyone will understand anything, yet the elderly, without having any basic knowledge about a computer, will be happy to use it to match horoscopes.

Even if someone designs an algorithm to predict future stock prices, it all has to be based upon historical data and publicly available market information. Nothing better than a computer matching horoscopes.

No quantitative model can work efficiently ever after to pick up the stock market winners month after month consistently.

This fund is nothing but “Old Wine in a New Bottle”. Same old fund management charges, same old stock selection tricks disguised in the name of quantitative models.

Investors may try their luck by betting!

Wednesday, 31 October 2007

How are the stock markets working?

How are the stock markets working?

Here is a short story that was delivered to our class at the Rotterdam School of Management, when we were LEARNING (or supposed to be learning) on “How to trade and make profits”.

This gentleman was a guest lecturer and came from a leading investment bank from London. He had more than 25 years of experience in trading – both on bonds and stocks. He introduced himself working at a real high rank in his organization and having almost 120 traders reporting to him. His words and presentation style reflected his experience.

He started by saying “So you all are here to learn trading and earn enormous profits? And you expect me to tell you how to do it? Right?”

Everyone looked convinced that he will teach us something worthwhile. However, he narrated an interesting story.
I’m putting it in my own words as below:

When Stock market trading started gaining momentum in the early 1980’s, there was a huge shortage of traders. Investment firms were finding it hard to find suitable individuals to whom they can teach trading and make them earn money for the firms. Moreover, individuals were not very enthusiastic about taking up trading as a career. Those who were willing to opt for it, were the ones who failed in other streams. This created a huge shortfall of “traders” in the market. So the investment firms and brokerage houses started looking around for people who can fit into their requirements.

The search ended at the vegetable markets. Yes- the “Sabji Mandi” of UK. (Sabji Mandi = Vegetable Market)

The vegetable vendors selling vegetables and fruits were laborious & hardworking salesmen (of vegetables) and had some typical characteristics. They had a very loud voice, which is required for survival in a Sabji Mandi. If they cannot shout, they cannot attract customers to buy vegetables from their stalls. Hence, they fit the requirement quite well, as during those days, there was no electronic trading in the stock market. All they had was a designated floor area, where stock traders interacted with each other. Shameless and loud voice was the need of the hour and was required to attract traders. Another criteria that these people fulfilled was that most of them had a well built physique with a good height – again good for attracting attention. Hence, the investment companies and brokerage houses picked up these tall, well built and loud voice humans to do trading for them and earn profit for the firm.

Actually, it worked quite well. As the stock market floor area was getting packed up with more and more people joining in – these long, high and noisy traders managed to carry on the business because they could be heard easily, could attract attention with their height and could also survive the pushing and pulling of the crowded floor area (and if required, throw out the lean individual traders)

However, markets are efficient and they have been efficient since long time. As more and more such tall and noisy traders came in, the floor area was filled only by these people. Other individuals started trading through agents, which used to be these same people taking order through hand signals. Technology crept in, telephones were used. Individuals started giving orders through phone.

Unfortunately, only loud voice and tall height was not sufficient to carry on trading in the efficient market. Hence, gradually, the investment firms started replacing these vegetable vendors with some more sophisticated and bit better educated salesmen. Physique and voice was no longer a requirement, as a lean fellow weighing only 40 Kilos could get his order executed on the phone. What was required was people who could understand money and finance, and make trades accordingly. Hence, the vegetable vendors were sent back to their original posts (Sabji Mandi) and somewhat educated salesmen took their places.

Things went on well for few years, but use of computers and technology took things on a different path. As people had historical stock data, they started to get into research. Valuation methods like DCF, etc. started becoming common. So called researchers were finally making way to evaluate stocks. The educated salesmen were no longer worth the job. Hence, trading positions then went to mathematicians, physicists and economists – especially the students from maths & economics. The salesmen returned to their sales jobs of door to door selling or working at showrooms.

Finally (and at present), the computer and internet have allowed everyone free access to data and valuation methods. Every smart alec sitting at home can now trade with his online account. Mathematicians, Physicists & economists with their limited knowledge about predicting stock prices and doing valuations were no longer required. As things became more and more efficient, MBA’s and PhD candidates with years of experience were hired to do trading and identify trends. They are the ones who are trading presently, and will continue to do so until the market identifies someone more efficient.

Story Ends:

What can you conclude from the above story? For us, the batch of students, it was just another proof of “No one can make extraordinary money from the market”.
Anyways, one thing can be clearly observed – everything is ruled by randomness. No level of knowledge can make anyone a master in stock picking or investments. For the ones those who still believe they can beat the market – all the best!

Link to previous article Indian Growth story and Investments


Have questions, please read the comments and post your views and queries in the comments section which helps in open discussion and avoids duplicity of questions.

You may be interested in reading my previous articles. Here is the link to Table of Contents in a chronological order.

Monday, 8 October 2007

Behavioural aspect of financial analysis

Financial Bloggers are often accused of one thing – repeating the same thing again and again and again. I agree with it; I tend to repeat things again and again.

Let me tell you one of my good experiences. I was about to finish my masters course at the Rotterdam School of Management. So, there was an informal session going on with one of my favourite professors. Having finished the course around 2 hours before time, he asked us if we had some questions that he may answer. My fellow students asked him about his past, his job profile (he was a full time trader previously), family, etc.

I posted a different question altogether:

What is the toughest question you’ve faced while teaching your students in finance?

It seemed as if he was just waiting for this question. He started by responding:

It’s not only the toughest question, but also the most embarrassing question – and this question repeatedly keeps on bugging the finance professors across the world.

He then continued:

“The toughest question every finance professors face, and even you may face someday, is: You teach several high caliber students about investments and trading. If you are so intelligent and smart about investments, finance and trading, why aren’t you rich?.”

The moment he said this, there was a big laugh in the class. However, after a moment, there was silence. The reason was that people realized what they had learned during the entire course and then (probably) they asked the same question to themselves. After spending so much money, taking a break from a well paid job, doing a costly course at an international business school, we were not in a position to answer the simple question.

Well, then we had a nice discussion about the reality of markets and financial products. What all we’ve learnt during the entire course, in a nut-shell was that “one cannot make enormous profits consistently in the market”. One may be lucky for 1, 2 or a few years – but how long can he carry on making profits – no one knows. Come together the fundas of diversification, asset allocation, tax saving, psychological biases, behavioural finance, disciplined approach, systematic investment plans, blah, blah, blah – all these terms factor in and ultimately the individual is left with no big profit in the end of everything.

My professor was already a trader with a reputed MNC financial firm and was based in New York. He said that the most interesting thing that he spotted during his career was how stupidly people behave with their money, how ignorant they are with respect to the financial products and markets, yet all this is done to get more money. Hardly anyone knows how to calculate the profits. Hardly anyone is willing to learn the right mathematics, but the moment there is a news on business channels, quoting EBITDA, Profit after tax, EPS, etc., etc., people will be fascinated about the numbers – though they hardly understand the meaning of those numbers. Brokers, investment advisors, agents & sometimes even organizations declaring financial results use these figure very well to make a fool of people. All they end up doing in the market is making bets.

In my previous articles, like DCF analysis, I attempted to give the right picture.

In my another article: Should you invest in IPO, I attempted to disclose the profit/loss calculation with respect to IPO applications.

Interestingly, for both these articles, people either responded by saying that they have not understood the method OR they picked up their best performing investments to prove that they are in big profits.

I’m not trying to say that you are in complete loss or not doing the right thing – but I’ve always advised to look at the whole picture. For example, you may have earned enormous profits in the recent IPO like Power grid IPO. However, look at the whole picture – let’s say past one year. How many IPO’s have you applied for? Were you allotted shares for all those IPOs which you applied for? How much was the profit that you made? Is the overall profit better than what you’ve lost in risk free bank accounts or FDs?

Similar thing goes for profit/loss calculations for stock trading and investments. Just take last 1 year or 2 year horizon or your entire investment horizon since when you started trading. Do a DCF analysis and see where you stand. Have you performed better than the risk free bond returns or bank account? If yes, have you performed better than the market – like those tracked by ETF? If yes, they can you continue doing so consistently year after year? If the answer to any of the above questions is no, then you must give a second thought to your investment strategies.

Well, sorry for repeating the same things again :- )
Thanks for reading till the end.


Have questions, please read the comments and post your views and queries in the comments section which helps in open discussion and avoids duplicity of questions.

You may be interested in reading my previous articles. Here is the link to Table of Contents in a chronological order.

Tuesday, 2 October 2007

DCF Analysis continued – I

Further to the Basic tutorial on DCF analysis with example - in this article I will highlight some more practicle uses of DCF analysis, by varying the investment returns and time horizon and how it impacts your investments.

Here is the original investment plan as covered in the Basic tutorial on DCF analysis with example:

Start Date

01-Jan-05

Investment Period

3 years

End Date

31-Dec-07

Interest Rate

9%

Present Value of

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

Date

Stock

Buy

Sold

Annualized time

PV-Buy

PV-Sold

01-Jan-05

Microsoft

(1,000.00)

-

(1,000.00)

-

03-Mar-05

GS

(200.00)

0.17

(197.14)

-

01-Dec-05

Google

(4,000.00)

0.92

(3,696.68)

-

10-Feb-06

Microsoft

1,200.00

1.11

-

1,090.57

11-Jul-06

Exxon

(5,000.00)

1.52

(4,384.89)

-

13-Sep-06

Amazon

(2,000.00)

1.70

(1,727.65)

-

19-Sep-06

AMX

(3,000.00)

1.72

(2,587.81)

-

28-Dec-06

GS

600.00

1.99

-

505.49

05-Jan-07

AMX

3,600.00

2.01

-

3,027.19

09-Jun-07

Google

(5,000.00)

2.44

(4,053.34)

-

10-Oct-07

Google

12,000.00

2.77

-

9,449.58

11-Oct-07

Exxon

5,500.00

2.78

-

4,330.03

31-Dec-07

Amazon

2,100.00

3.00

-

1,621.97

Total

(20,200.00)

25,000.00

(17,647.52)

20,024.82

Net (Sold-Buy)

4,800.00

2,377.31

Net % Return

23.76%

13.47%

Annualized % Return

7.37%

4.30%

As we can observe, the Net % return is positive, since ALL the investments are considered to the positive (as displayed in the table below):

Buy

Sell

% Profit

Microsoft

-1000

1200

20.00%

GS

-200

600

200.00%

Google

-9000

12000

33.33%

Exxon

-5000

5500

10.00%

AMX

-3000

3600

20.00%

Amazon

-2000

2100

5.00%

TOTAL

-20200

25000

23.76%

Continue to Part II


Copyright Information:
© http://invest-n-trade.blogspot.com
Please see Our Copy Right Policy. All the articles, posts and other materials on this website/blog are copyrighted to the owners of this portal. The content should NOT to be reproduced on any other website or through other medium, without the author's AND owners' permission.

DISCLAIMER: Before using this site, you agree to the Disclaimer.

About UsAdvertise with UsCopyRight Policy & Fair Use GuidePrivacy PolicyDisclaimer